Ohio Democratic and Green Gubernatorial Nominees to Debate Each Other; No Other Ohio Gubernatorial Debate Planned

Ohio is one of only three states this year with a gubernatorial election, and in which the Democratic and Republican nominees won’t be debating each other. The other such states are Nevada and Tennessee.

However, the Ohio Democratic gubernatorial nominee, Ed FitzGerald, will debate the only other gubernatorial nominee on the ballot, Anita Rios of the Green Party, on October 22. See this story.

Indiana Appeals Decision That Invalidated Limited Nominations for Political Parties in Indianapolis Judicial Races

On October 17, Indiana appealed Common Cause Indiana v Indiana Secretary of State to the 7th Circuit. This is the case over whether Indiana can tell political parties that they can only nominate for half the seats up, in partisan judicial races in Indianapolis. U.S. District Court Judge Richard Young had invalidated the system on October 9.

Limited nominations laws were passed to keep the dominant political party from winning all the seats. In other jurisdictions with limited nominations laws, such as Pennsylvania, Connecticut, and the District of Columbia, limited nomination laws make it possible for independent and minor party candidates to more easily win. But Indiana has very strict ballot access laws, so minor party and independent candidates almost never get on the ballot for judge in Indianapolis. As a consequences, voters inevitably face a general election ballot with only Democrats and Republicans. Since each of those parties can only run for half the seats, the voters have no real choice; all the candidates on the ballot automatically win. The last time anyone other than a Democrat or a Republican ran was in 2002, when a single Libertarian ran.

One of the oddest parts of the U.S. District Court decision is that Judge Young found that Common Cause has standing to challenge the system. Normally, a restriction on the ability of a political party to nominate as many candidates as it wishes would be challenged by a political party, but in this case, no political party complained.