Comments

Politico Lists the 538 Presidential Electors for 2016 — 30 Comments

  1. IF the gerrymander oligarchs want to avoid Civil WAR II, then they must abolish the super time bomb anti-Democracy minority rule gerrymander Electoral College.

    What percentage of such left/right extremist HACK oligarchs WANT a Civil WAR II ???
    ——–
    Uniform definition of Elector-Voter in ALL of the USA.
    P.R. and nonpartisan App.V.

  2. Demo Rep, don’t know how many times you need to be told this. It’s impossible to Gerrymander the Electoral College. The electors are awarded state-wide in all but two states. Do you even know what gerrymandering is?

  3. As for CA, has anyone seen a ballot in the State that has the following statement on it: “To vote for all of the electors of a party, stamp cross (+) in the square opposite the name of a party and its, presidential and vice presidential candidate is a vote for all of the electors
    of that party, but for no other candidates.” ? Also, has any one seen any county issued ballot in California that shows squares opposite the names on any of the six
    qualified parties in CA?

  4. The notion that Republican electors should switch to Clinton is doomed. Keep in mind that neither Trump or Clinton got 50% of the vote, meaning that most people voted against both of them. Why should Republican electors switch their votes to someone who is only a shade less unpopular than Trump?

    IMO, a better strategy would be to encourage Republican electors to vote for a third candidate, one who is popular and well known enough to draw just enough electoral votes away from Trump to throw the election into the House. There, Democrats should back this third candidate, and encourage Republican Reps to support this third choice.

    Who might that third candidate be? I don’t know for sure, but it would probably some well known anti-Trump Republican. Possibilities include Mitt Romney, Mario Rubio, or Rand Paul.

  5. Mark,

    That language almost looks like it dates from the time when you could vote for individual elector candidates, and that box permitted you to vote a straight ticket for all the electors of an individual party.

    In 1912, you could vote for individual elector candidates, because that was the reason that the electoral votes were split between Wilson and Roosevelt. There were disputes in that election whether votes cast for all the electors of a party had been properly reported in the canvass, and that box might have been added to make it easy for a voter who wished to vote for all electors of a slate to do so.

    In 2016, you could not vote for individual electors.

    So it was changed somewhere in between. Richard Winger probably knows when.

    The Elections Code for presidential elections should be placed in a single Division, instead of being scattered throughout the Elections Code.

    Presidential Preference Primary

    Use the 2000 format where all voters could vote for any potential presidential candidate, including independent candidates. Ballots would be marked with the party preference of each voter so that votes may be tabulated by party.

    Candidates, including potential independent candidates would be identified by the SOS. Political parties could identify additional candidates, and candidates could file for inclusion (fee or petition).

    Each political party would be able to designate which candidates it was considering for potential nomination, and which voters would be considered as relevant to its nomination process.

    A presidential candidate could request that their name be removed from the ballot, or that they not be considered for nomination by a particular party.

    So for example, it would have been up to the Green Party whether Sanders or Clinton could have become the nominee of the Green Party. And even if the Green Party would consider votes for Sanders or Clinton, it would be up to Sanders and Clinton whether they wanted to be considered for nomination by the Green Party. An individual Green voter could still vote for Sanders or Clinton, regardless of the wishes of the party or the candidate.

    Candidates would qualify for the general election by receiving the most votes of a party or receiving 1% of the total vote.

    In 2000, Gore [DEM, NLP], Bradley, McCain [AI, LBT, REF], Bush [REP], Keyes, and Nader [GRE] would have qualified.

    Political parties could do what they may wish with the vote totals (e.g. choose delegates to the national convention, etc.)

    Extended Presidential Preference Primary

    Additional candidates could qualify, based on the support of non-primary voters. To facilitate this, a ballot would be prepared with all non-qualified candidates. Candidates who no longer wished to qualify could request their removal, and transfer their support to other candidates. Primary write-in candidates who received cognizable support (say 1000 votes) would be added.

    In 2000, this ballot could have included Browne 20,825; LaRouche 19,419; Trump 15,311; Forbes 14,484; Bauer 10,529; Weber 9,390; Hatch 9,202; Phillips 8,979; Kovel 6,714; Hagelin 5,891; Bowman 4,879; Lee 4,009; Smith 3,165; Anderson 3,158; Hines 2,984; Hollist 2,487; and Collins 1,837.

    The target would be just over 76,000 (1% of the primary vote).

    This post-primary ballot would be strictly non-partisan. Voters who did not vote in the primary could vote at area voting locations or by mail. Instead of circulating petitions, candidates could assist in mail ballot applications. New registrants would also receive a ballot.

    Presidential General Election

    Presidential candidates would apply for the general election ballot, using the support from the presidential preference primary as the basis of a modicum of support.

    A qualified candidate need not apply for the general election ballot. If the nominee of a party chose not to run, there would be no replacement.

    The presidential candidate would identify his vice-presidential candidate and which if any of his party nominations he accepted. The presidential candidate would also identify his presidential elector and alternate candidates. The vice-presidential and elector candidates would have to assent.

    Qualifications for elector candidates might include California residency, and possibly district residency.

    A vote for the presidential candidate would be a vote for his elector candidates.

  6. I agree with Walter. The idea that a Republican Elector would vote for Hillary Clinton is delusional. Voting for a third party or an alternative Republican would be an easier sell. Even so, Trump has 290 Electoral Votes confirmed, with possibly 16 more (he’s leading in Michigan), so at least 21 electors (possibly 37) would have to be flipped. Even one faithless elector is rare; this number would be unheard of.

  7. One possibility is for electors abstaining or casting protest votes for a third candidate. This wouldn’t elect Clinton, but it would deny Trump a majority, sending it to the House. At worst, this would force Republican members (including a few in districts that were close or voted for Clinton) to take a public and decisive stand for Trump (which could later be used against them); at best, it could bring enough new states into the The National Popular Vote Interstate Compact to kill the Electoral College

  8. AMc — Sorry — each State is a de facto gerrymander area — even if semi-permanent.

    See the 4 gerrymander E.C. districts in ME and NE in 2016 — 2 each.

    1/2 or less votes x 1/2 gerrymander areas having a bare majority of the total EC Votes 538 in 2016) = 1/4 or less —

    Reality each Prez has been getting de facto elected by about 30 percent of the total voters since 1832.

    How many States have been really somewhat marginal in E.C. gerrymander math — within 5 percent — since 1832 ???

    i.e. will the same about 10 States be the so called *battleground States* in 2020 — IF the USA survives that long.

  9. @demo Rep

    Let me guess you are a whiny ass Hillary supporter that doesnt care about common knowledge that she has been behind many MANY racial, class and political mishaps, to say the least. Yes trump is no presidental canidate by any means, but many people will die if Hillary ever gets near that office again. So instead of throwing mud with some BS story about how “oh im so oppressed”, get out there and do something if you feel so oppressed. Democrats have ruined this country, we have been walked over by countires and ideologies for far too long. American blood spilled on American soil carried out by enemies of the nation, should be a call to arms for all americans with a spine unlike yourself demo rep

  10. commonsense — Both the EVIL Donkey and Elephant oligarchy gangsters have done their EVIL in the USA and in the world for many, many decades.

    Each Prez is a figurehead for the oligarchs involved – leftists or rightists.

  11. Let’s be real. A Trump presidency will make this nation a fascist state. He has no business being President, I believe there are democrats and republicans that believe this. The election was high jacked by the gerrymandering and the FBI director making his statement of Hillary’sEmails that amounted to nothing. It was unprecedented. So the fate of this democracy lies in another unprecedented move and that is not giving Trump the electors needed and allowing the president who won by the popular vote. Even Trump was opposed to the electoral college and said this election was rigged.

  12. Ok, Morons, the Electoral College was invented specifically for a situation such as the one we are facing — the election of a candidate who does not possess the qualifications or temperament to serve as President of the United States. However, the institution has been bastardized by state laws that require electors to vote according to the popular vote of those states. This undermines the very intent of the Electoral College! What we have right now is a fabricated “win” by Donald Trump. Clinton has won the popular vote by over 1 million votes (likely double that number by the time all votes are counted. If the Electoral College were to work as intended, Clinton would win, not Trump! It is only through the artificial mechanism of state laws preventing the electors to vote their conscience that Trump has been declared the winner. So, yes, we could eventually get rid of the Electoral College (but that would be impossible to accomplish by December 19th). Better still, we can implore the electors to vote their conscience, not the party (or state) line — as they are supposed to do. And we can then push for Electoral College reform, restoring it to be the “safeguard” it is intended to be.

  13. Dear EC electors,
    More than any other time in US history, we implore you to do your moral job and cast your EC votes for Hillary Clinton, the true people’s choice by close to 2.8 million popular votes!

    Donald Trump CHEATED to get elected on many levels, and by colaberating with a foreign power to do so, commited treason as well!
    This is a fact, and more details are under investigation right now, but clearly, many Republican players are involved as well, at Trump’s request!
    We all heard his request to Putin on TV!

    Several of Trump’s utterly inappropriate and/or unqualified appointments, like Mitch McConnell’s wife, were payment for his help in this act of treason!

    Trump calls man made climate change a “hoax”, which is literally, a human extinction level of science denial, and he has set out to assure our extinction over generations, or at least, the destruction of our government agencies, with his “burn it all down” appointments and idiotic “privatize EVERYTHING” policies…

    The thousands of “conflicts of interest”, all over the world, are obvious, and putting his children in charge of his businesses and part of his team, is in fact a family run corporate Dictatorship.

    His staff selections have shown a total disregard for America AND the world, as if his intention REALLY WAS to burn it all down!

    He is inappropriately fascinated with using nuclear weapons and having MORE nuclear armed countries in the world, not less!

    His irrational behavior recently, as well as during both the primary and general campaigns horrified America and the world, with nothing but lies, hate, paranoia, insults toward ANYONE and everyone, and vitriol, just like but more irrational than his intellectual mentor… Adolph Hitler! The parallels are obvious!

    Most horrifying, however, is that he is mentally unhinged! He is clearly a sociopath, appears to have ADHD, and definitely, Narcissistic personality disorder, as well as ULTRA thin skinned anger issues! (Possibly a drug habit)..

    He has a childlike speech problem, with a 200 word vocabulary, and a 15 minute attention span.

    He is uninterested in and refuses to listen to most security briefs, saying he does not need them because, “he is very smart”.

    He has embraced and emboldened the bowels of American society, (like the KKK and NAZI PARTY), and is as well as encourages total civil upheaval, with his xenophobia, homophobia, misogyny, bigotry, violence, and total lack of compassion for anyone except himself!

    Trump is also a career con man/criminal and sexual preditor, (with numerous trials pending), and has no idea at all how to run this once great country. He will destroy all that we hold dear…

    He is a pathological liar that PolitiFact considers “the liar of the year”, while they consider Hillary “the most honest of the 20 who ran”!

    For the most part, none of the “Swift Boating” and dishonest Hillary bashing was true! She is 10,000 X more qualified to be POTUS!

    Trump’s insane fascist agenda of promoting kayos, hate and paranoia worldwide, while also helping his businesses around the world, and making decisions “for America” in that vein, will destroy us all!

    Clearly, Hillary Clinton is one of the most qualified people imaginable, and Donald Trump (as Dictator), is the least qualified, mentally unstable, and MOST DANGEROUS person that could have control of our nuclear codes and our country!

    UNDER DONALD TRUMP, AMERICA WILL FALL, and he may well blunder us into another Great Depression or possibly, WW III !

    In the name of saving us all, PLEASE… Place your vote for Hillary Clinton!

    Thank you for considering my request,
    Mark Johnson

  14. Today Donald Trump announced that he has cancelled the Press Conference he was supposed to hold later this week to let us know how he is planning to deal with his business interests while serving as POTUS in such a way as to not cause conflicts of interest between his business interests and his responsibilities for and to the United States government and the American people. It is already abundantly clear that avoiding such conflicts may be impossible and put the interests of the American people at risk. It is essential that before any elector votes to confirm him as POTUS that he reveal to the nation how he will avoid such conflicts, that his plan be realistic, and enforceable. Otherwise, as electors representing the national interest you have a responsibility to not elect Donald Trump President.

  15. First, there has been NO prove whatever that DT knew or assisted in Wikileaks exposing the truth or that he was in with the not so great anymore russian bear! Karma got HiLiar and her group. You as an American want to stay blinded? That is what the elitist want. Their narrative is to keep the average American out of the loop. There is no way HiLiar and the clinton crime family are getting in WH. Stein and Soro’s recount scam proved there was no fraud . Unless you count the 6 votes for every one cast in Wayne County,MI. for HRC. But MSM not talking about that. DT did not have to run. Ran to try and get US(A) out of the serfdom that the elitist Dem and Gop puppets have doomed our nation to become. Even brainwashed sheeples can see something is going on here that stinks! All the underhanded moves by Soros-HiLiar and Olamo didn’t work. There’s that Karma again. The people voted for change or at least to go down fighting as an American and not as a sheep! Follow the simple plan they’ve laid out to get whom they want: not what or whom Americans want.A.Conceded then did not denounce civil unrest. Some using Soros funded hate groups like BLIESm. B. Recount at last possible moment to try and throw the numbers to HRC or from DT. C.Allow EC members to be threatened. In PA case publishing addresses and phone numbers of Electors. This by the PA Dem. Governor! Again HRC or Olamo did not denounce! D. Rehash June,2016 hack story thru MSM, WP, whom admitted was not verified. And CIA insiders denied that there was any such prove of DT’s involvement. The NYT quoted WP and ALL other sources quoted NYT and WP. Both had been shown, along with CNN to conspire at various times with HRC campaign. That story came out after the recount effort failed. And between Friday night and the Sunday morning talk shows it changed with no further prove offered just WH and CIA said so! E.Conceded HiLiar had, I had my Gmail hacked, Podesta on social media screaming for the EC to be briefed before they vote! F. Then , low and behold, 10 EC members ,led by Nancy Pelosi’s daughter, no conflict here, demand that they be briefed. We should all demand to be briefed. I can’t wait to see what G-Z’s plans are! You know they have them. We the People were suppose to stay We the Sheeples. The status quo will fight. But as the Founding Fathers called the masses, the beast. We will not sit by and be ignored or screwed over again and again. If you really believe in election fraud, and I do believe major changes are needed. The perfect state to audit is CA. But you’ll see how fast CA fights that if it’s suggested! but now is not the time. The powers to be may call what I’ve said as delusional or paranoid. But just because your paranoid doesn’t mean there’s no one out to get you! Today it’s maybe the candidate you don’t want. But next time it just may be yours that gets screwed and if you’ve done nothing then you are truly are a sheep.

  16. It’s a shame that both sides continue to use faules words of carricurture. Proof of facts MUST BE THE ANSWER, the records will eventually take place. Most remarks are from frustration not TRUTH. Every body is an expert, that’s why we’re RUNNING THE FUTURE USA. PAUSE RELAX AN HELP

  17. Morons all of you. The only qualification to be president (besides age) is to be born an American Citizen and to be elected. That happened. Qualification met. We are a REPUBLIC not a democracy. We have an electoral college to prevent mob rule. We are a republic to prevent mob rule and protect the mobs intended victims. So you can scream all you want and act like a vicious mob, it will not negate that there are enough people who voted for Trump to give him the electoral votes needed to win. How dare you decide that ONLY YOUR opinions and votes count and not theirs as well? How dare you try to steal the rights and votes of the rest of the country’s citizens as though their lives were irelevant and less important than yours! Can’t you see the rest of the people in this country are tired of elitists who think that everyone who does not subscribe to your opinions is a 5 year old child who needs you to decide for them what is best. That is why you lost. Trump voters are people who have suffered severly under 8 years of Obama.That is why you lost. Its time to remember that other people, other AMERICANS, have to live in this country too and have a vote and a right to participate in how the government will be run as well.

  18. ARepublican your Republican party is not the Republican party I would Support.My Republican party is Senator Jeff Flake of Arizona.votes by common Americans should not count.Its time we have death squads here in America.

  19. A military coup should occur and a military dictatorship.A Republican you are a fool.I hope you lose your job under Trump and your gas is 4.00 a gallon.

  20. AMcCarrick,
    DemoRep is obviously a paid democratic organizer and antagonizer. The facts of how our election process (as well as the laws of our country for that matter) are irrelevant to him. He is only concerned with Democrats winning *at all costs*. He is one of those who will be all up in arms about a comment asking second ammendment supporters to vote against clinton, but will then turn around and write posts threatening “Civil War II” when Clinton loses.

    He obviously has no concern with democratic process, rule of law, good of the people, etc. He is basically “give me what i want or i will do whatever it takes, even hurt you to get it”. Its basically the same philosophy of every terrorist, despot, dictator, nazi, or communist in all of the annals of history and one should really take notice of these posts where he reveals his true colors, because guys like him are just like domestic abusers, in that they have their sweet syrupy public personas, but their true ugly, despotic, misogynistic, evil natures show when they do not get what they want, and should never be forgotten. I’m glad he got on here and is showing this side of himself and his Democratic Party supporters so Americans can see what these hate groups are really about.

    Its usually useless having a meaningful discussion with people like him and other members of his Democrats/hate groups because they are not concerned with truth, making the best decision, heck, even the goodwill of anybody they are involved with. They are only concerned with winning, and, just like Hillary and the other Democrats they represent, they will say whatever is necessary in any given context, to achieve what they think is best to say to get what they want.

  21. I’ve read these boards a lot this past year and someone calling DemoRep a Democratic Party operative is about the funniest thing I’ve seen.

  22. To all EC,
    We, the people, thank you for supporting and respecting our decisions as people, created equal, under the constitution of the United States. We are tired of people constantly trying to disregard our wishes and needs as good citizens of your state, and our nation. We are a nation set up under the premise that the government is of the people, by the people, and for the people, which, as some who are posting here obviously do not understand, means respecting the obligations of your oaths of office and represeting the will of the people.

    We very much respect and appreciate your understanding of your roles as members of our government who respect the fact that the government serves at the will of the people. It is horribly unfortunate you are being harrassed, threatened, and cajoled into trying to control the people and disregard their will by rejecting and replacing their wishes, mostly by people who only a few weeks ago were in almost riot about statements that the results of an election may not be recognized. I’m sure to good people like yourselves, their aggrgious hypocrisy and lack of understanding of political service is easily recognizable and as appalling to you as for most good American citizens.

    I am sure you are aware of this, but it is obvious that people who support an admistration who has tried to use the IRS to serve its political bidding, and has used the white house and congress as their professional wealth building tools would not be able to understand the idea of moral obligations to the citizens being served, but i apologize to you on behalf of the many silent Americans (who spoke up on Nov 8th) for these Democrat ogranized/ Communist hate groups working so hard to organize and direct against you as faithful servants of America, such awful, immature behaviour within our political process.

    If it is still needed, it may help to hear again that basically every point being used to try to convince you against Trump is a trait which was shown to a more dedicated and devious degree by Hillary and her Democratic campaign. From theft of government resources, to misogyny and racism, to use of political offie for self serving gains, Hillary beats Trump in every category with respect to one: Hillary is a much better career politician and is much better in hiding her true feelings and wording everything exactly peoperly to make sure nobody is ever offended. She is also good at making sure when she says different things to different groups she does not get found out, which was very useful in getting votes from American citizens who do not know when she says conflicting things but can also be useful in deciving other countries as well.

    Unfortunately, being a great liar i think does not tip the scales in favor of ones character as a president. Trump may be a little thin skinned but id rather have a president that gets angry than one who considers it acceptable business to make millions of $$ by promising special treatment to Russian nuclear Uranium mining companies and Saudi Oil Shieks, and other foreign entities through the use of her political offices.

    I urge you to vote the will of your people. There are a great many Americans who still believe in the rule of law and the value of public servants being loyal to their citizens. These Americans saw Hillary for the corrupt person she was and voted against her. As you can see, there is nobody trying to convince/ harrass Hillary electoral voters to be disloyal to the citizens of their state and country. Most good Americans who genuinely believe in Democracy and freedom, are again showing the difference between them and Hillary supporters by *not* harrassing Democratic electors to change their votes. It is telling that the followers of Hillary are rioting, damaging and attacking Americans, ignoring our immigration laws, and now trying to intimidate/ coerce our electors to betray their oaths of office. It rings very hollow and should to you, when these same people speak of obligation to the nation and election system, when they are behaving as they are. It’s like the abusive husband who says he will be good, he’s so sorry, as long as you let him back in the house again. These are the people harrassing you and sending letters. Do not be deceived by their syrupy new message. They are the same who were talking about rioting and burning things only a couple weeks ago.

    You should look at the facts of the candidates, and the source of all this harrassment and the type of people they are, and feel good in your decision to support the will of your people and be loyal to your oath of office and your citizens you represent.

    thank you for all you do

  23. I am a disabled female Vietnam Vet and I am afraid if Donald Trump is voted to be my President he will tear our Country further apart than he has already. He has financial holdings all over the world which is in conflict with constitution. He says there’s no complication in resolving this issue yet his own campaign advisor said it was complicated. Why didn’t he have the Press conference and let you the Electors see how he was going to divest himself of his holdings. Secondly, why has he repudiated our highest security offices of our land and not supported action against Russia for hacking into governmental process to favor his election. I’m very afraid that he has not in any shape, form or Voice attempted to heal the great divide in our Country. Yet he has plenty of time to go on so called “thank you” tours to feed his egotistical need for approval. He is not fit to be yours or my President. He is thinned skin, crude and disrespectful to anyone who minutely disagrees with him. This full comment above is in my humble opinion and pray you each rethink your previous vote and do not vote him into office.

  24. When a person is put into the Oval Office they have no business near it, the system we are following needs to be examined and changed! This Country should be burning already, it has been deceived and is a pawn in a deadly game being played by the massa’s in Washington! The massas have always been in Washington, hey, don’t use the N word and the color of your skin does not matter! Never has! WAKE THE HELL UP! You are the N’s, Washington guards the massa’s!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.