U.S. District Court in New York Upholds District Attorney’s Subpoena for President Trump’s Tax Returns

On October 7, U.S. District Court Judge Victor Marrero upheld a subpoena by the Manhattan District Attorney for President Donald Trump’s tax returns for the last several years. Trump v Vance, s.d., 1:19cv-8694. The subpoena has no connection with the New York state law allowing the state government to release the Trump tax returns. Instead it involves a criminal investigation against the President. Here is the 75-page opinion.

Judge Marrero is a Clinton appointee who was born in Puerto Rico.

The President immediately asked for a stay from the Second Circuit, which granted it. In the Second Circuit the case is 19-3204.

In California, the Secretary of State has still not appealed the U.S. District Court opinion in the tax returns-ballot case. It may be that the California Secretary of State believes the tax returns may emerge through the activity of the New York and District of Columbia pending cases.


Comments

U.S. District Court in New York Upholds District Attorney’s Subpoena for President Trump’s Tax Returns — 15 Comments

  1. Since when can a Prez NOT be prosecuted for TREASON, MURDER, ESPIONAGE [ESP WAR PLANS AND WAR CODES], OR THROWING TRASH ON THE WHITE HOUSE LAWN ???

    ARE THE 4 JULY 1776 DOI FOLKS SPINNING IN THEIR GRAVES ??? —

    DOI — LIST OF COMPLAINTS AGAINST ***TYRANT*** BRIT KING GEORGE III AND HIS HACKS IN THE 1776 BRIT PARLIAMENT.

    PROBLEM –
    LOTS OF COPYING OF BRIT STRUCTURE ROT PARTS INTO THE 1775-1787 STATE CONST. AND LATER 1787 USA CONST.

    NEW SET OF DOMESTIC TYRANTS ???

    PR AND APPV AND TOTSOP

  2. The current opinion is, a President can’t be charged with a crime will in office, from The Office of Legal Counsel, an office in the United States Department of Justice that assists the Attorney General’s position as legal adviser to the President and all executive branch agencies. It was never decided in the Supreme Court. Today, a Judge said it doesn’t mean the crime can’t be investigated. As part of the Impeachment language, crime(s) can be charged after impeachment, or no impeachment, then when they leave office, in federal or civilian court. There is no pardon or double jeopardy option.

  3. FATAL – OLC-DOJ HACKS – TOTALLY CONTROLLED BY FELON PREZS / tyrants — with JUNK LAWLESS *policies*.

    Most Fed crimes- 6 year statute limitations ??? —

    How many Trump gang USA crimes in 2015-2018 ???

    More FATAL – FELON Prez power to pardon own crimes and fellow gangster FELONS.

    Too many MORONS in DC media to count.

    —-
    AppV — NONPARTISAN SEPARATE ELECTIONS OF USA MARSHALS AND USA DIST ATTYS.

    TOTSOP

  4. Reminder-

    Trump PURGE of AG Sessions and FBI Comey.

    A LAWLESS TYRANT at work.

    RED commie Donkeys too paralyzed to IMPEACH the TYRANT —

    and propose CRISIS Art V Amdts —

    regardless of ALL Elephant stooge hacks in H Reps and Senate defending the LAWLESS TYRANT Prez.

  5. Why do people care so much about his tax returns? What major party candidate with a chance isn’t rich?

  6. Earlier-

    1642-1649 TYRANT king Charles I vs Parliament in English Civil WAR – KCI convicted of Treason – head chopped.

    — MAJOR shock in all the then rotted evil *divine right of kings* monarch regimes in Europe.

    1688-1689- TYRANT king James II – fled England — 1689 Brit Bill of Rights Act.

    1775-1776 – TYRANT king George III – DOI roast of his TYRANT actions

    1776-1784 State Consts — ALL putting major limits on top execs [esp State guvs].

    NOW – one more TYRANT crisis in Western Civilization — as if the KILLER tyrants have not been enough —

    Napoleon, Napoleon III, Bismarck, Kaiser Bill, Lenin, Mussolini, Hirohito, Stalin, Hitler, Mao, etc.

  7. Harry Truman was very poor. After he left the presidency he and his wife had to live with Truman’s mother-in-law. There were no presidential pensions back then.

  8. NOT enough RED communists giving Truman cash ???

    esp after Truman losing Eastern Europe regimes and China to RED communists ???

    How much of govt spending now for *pensions* [aka *transfer payments*] in USA econ accounts in BEA.

    Current MONARCH $$$ *pension* for ex-Prezs ???

  9. me-

    Obviously RED commie Dems want to purge Trump about —-

    any emolument stuff
    Un-reported income
    foreign income sources
    fake deductions
    NON-payments to RED charities
    etc.–
    *effective* Fed income tax rate = Fed tax / GROSS income PCT.

    aka ALSO weaponize the 16th Amdt to destroy opponents.

  10. Will NY try to go direct to SCOTUS — taking note of CA ballot access-tax stuff ???

    IE – NOW to 20 Jan 2021 — Election law Battle Stations for poor SCOTUS clerks.

  11. The Dist Ct op has all the now rotted *doctrines* dreamed up by the SCOTUS HACKS.

    Con Law 000001

    The USA Const and *valid* USA laws and treaties are the Supreme law of ye olde land.

    ALL acts or omissions are legal or illegal — facially or as *applied* – 2x2x2 = 8.

    The USA and State regimes are separate and unequal.

    Each regime can NOT obstruct the *legal* actions of the other regime.

    There are USA legal defenses for legal USA actions – esp the above *supreme* law.

    See 1st post at top.

    On to SCOTUS ASAP – to get more earlier SCOTUS JUNK over-ruled — about *abstention*, injunctions, etc.

  12. “me” The people who want to see a Presidential candidate’s tax returns want to see where the candidate’s money comes from. It’s not how much, but from what source. It doesn’t matter to me, but that is their reasoning.

  13. How much of the Trump campaign $$$ BIG CASH *donations* will magically appear in the Trump gang’s personal checking accounts ???

    How much did from the 2013-2016 Trump campaign — NOT reported as Trump USA/NY income ???

  14. The law makes everyone tax returns private, 26 U.S. Code § 6103.Confidentiality and disclosure of returns and return information. Some information may be released to other government entities, but only for good reason. A lot of hate here, but no amount of hate should influence the judges. The voting booth is where you take out your hatefulness.

    If he were laundering campaign money, it would not appear in his official tax returns, believe you me.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.