Minor Party, Independent Presidential Candidates May Have Tipped 4 States

Apparently, as of 10:20 Pacific time, there are four states in which no presidential candidate won as much as 50% of the vote. According to this excellent Associated Press website, those 4 states are:

1. North Carolina: Obama 49.9%, McCain 49.5%, Barr .6%

2. Montana: McCain 48.6%, Obama 48.1%, Paul 2.1%, Nader .9%, Barr .3%

3. Indiana: Obama 49.9%, McCain 49.0%, Barr 1.1%

4. Missouri: McCain 49.6%, Obama 49.1%, Nader .6%, Barr .4%, Baldwin .3%.

As the night goes on, these percentages will change slightly.


Comments

Minor Party, Independent Presidential Candidates May Have Tipped 4 States — 10 Comments

  1. Indiana is not so. Lake County was the difference on a late tally that was 70%+ Obama and put him over the top.

  2. For any of those states to have tipped the other way would require assuming implausible behavior by the voters. There were no spoilers in the 2008 presidential election.

  3. One thing to think about is that for people that voted for a third party candidate, that is who they wanted to vote for. I was not taking a vote away from McCain because he never had my vote to begin with.

  4. Georgia Libertarians had a great night. In Georgia candidates must get 50% to win an election and avoid a runoff. It appears that Allen Buckley (U.S. Senate) and Brandon Givens (Public Service Commission) both caused Dec. runoffs.

    Also, additional BIG news is that John Monds (candidate for Public Service Commission, which is a statewide election) broke the 1,000,000 vote mark! PLUS, he won at least two large Metro Atlanta counties (DeKalb and Clayton).

    Results are here: http://sos.georgia.gov/elections/election_results/2008_1104/swall.htm

  5. Richard:
    Don’t forget Nebraska’s second district (Omaha) electoral vote. Latest results show McCain ahead by about 500; Nader has 1502; McKinney 292.

  6. I think that the minor party vote needs to be at least twice the difference between the old party candidates for this to have been likely, since many minor candidate supporters would not vote for an old party candidate. And with relatively strong independent candidates all over the ideological spectrum, it’s even harder to know.

  7. 96% of precincts reporting

    Saxby Chambliss Republican 1,838,787 49.9%
    Jim Martin Democratic 1,720,931
    46.7%
    Allen Buckley Libertarian 125,998 3.4%

    wow, can’t get any closer than that… I guess it depends on absentee ballots, etc… hopefully they tilt DEM and force that runoff…

  8. The most plausible case can be for North Carolina, but that is more in terms of two candidates who were kept off the ballot (McKinney and Nader). Had they been on the ballot and polled in similar numbers to Virginia or South Carolina they would combined received about 0.6%. Baldwin would more likely have drawn from Barr.

  9. Thanks to the Libertarians, the Dems will have Prez-elect Obama in GA making sure Chambliss loses that seat in the run-off.

    The Repugs have no one but themselves to blame for not adopting instant runoff voting.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.