On April 21, the New York Supreme Court, Appellate Division, Fourth District, invalidated the new U.S. House district boundaries as an unconstitutional partisan gerrymander. The decision is based on the State Constitution. Harkenrider v Hochul, 22-00506. The vote is 3-2. Both dissenters, Justices Gerald J. Whalen and Joanne M. Winslow, are Democrats. The majority comprises Republican Justice John V. Centra, and Democratic Justices Stephen K. Lindley and John M. Curran. Here is the decision. Thanks to ElectionLawBlog for the link.
The order gives the legislature until April 30 to draw new districts. It is extremely likely that the case will be appealed to the state’s highest state court, the Court of Appeals.
PR — since 1840s -1840s
Puerto Rico has been around longer than that.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proportional_representation
USA in ANTI-Democracy gerrymander STONE AGE since 1776 – due to rotted Brits since 1200s.
What do you have against the Magna Carta?
King John attempted to wipe out the 1215 MC —
esp the enforcement part on him.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magna_Carta
Fortunately for Western Civilization he died in 1216 —
Took until 1600s for end of tyrant monarchs in England/UK
— with 1760-1820 KG 3 throwback [as noted in the USA 1776 DOI]
MC Chap 29 still around via DP cls in 5 Amdt and 14-1 Amdt.
How was England better off before the 1200s?
@Q…. Uhh huh? Pretty sure az is saying that things weren’t good until the Magna Carta which was implemented in 1215. Are you reading what is actually written or choosing to read what you think is written?
az is Thomas Jones. It has proven many times he only types retarded jibberish
“Rotted since 1200s” means things got better in the 1200s? In which language?
Arden’s question might be better asked to herself.
1066 — ENGLAND CONQUERED BY INVADERS FRON NORMANDY — tyrant monarchs to 1689.
late 1200s — gerrymanders in formation of English House of Commons —
got worse and worse to 1832
1600s — infected brit-am colonies
1776 — all States infected
1789 — USA regime infected
TOO MANY TROLL MORONS TO COUNT.
P.R. NOW TO SAVE WESTERN CIVILIZATION.
Did England not have tyrant monarchs before 1066?
Was what became the US better off before 1776?
Who here do you think is a troll moron?
And why?
https://www.yahoo.com/news/straightening-lines-n-y-appellate-081000840.html
NY highest Court argument Tues 26 Apr 2022
You failed to answer.