On October 13, the Virginia Republican Party voted to use a convention, not a primary, for the U.S. Senate race in 2008. The vote was 47-37. Those who support a convention said one reason they voted for a convention was that they don’t want outsiders helping choose the Republican nominee. Although the party won a lawsuit on October 1 in the 4th circuit on this matter, the ruling only applies when the party is being forced to hold a primary. In this instance, the decision was the party’s to make, so the ruling doesn’t apply.
Virginia law lets incumbents who are running for re-election dictate whether the party will use a convention or a primary. In the case of the U.S. Senate race, no Republican is running for re-election. Incumbent Senator John Warner is retiring.
A Republican convention should favor former Gov. Jim Gilmore over the moderate U. S. Rep. Tom Davis. Former Gov. Mark Warner will apparently be unopposed on the Democratic side, and if the Republicans had a primary, more Democrats could be expected to cross over and vote for Davis than for Gilmore.
The incumbent gets to choose. This does not seem like equal protection.
Look for a lawsuit in the future against the Incumbent Protection Act.