Yesterday a blog post appeared here about a proposed California initiative to use Approval Voting in the primary for partisan office. The initiative would not affect the top-two system. The two candidates in the primary who received the most approval votes would be the only candidates in November.
In the context of the 2026 California election, if this system were in place, chances are almost all the statewide offices in November would consist of two Democrats on the November ballot, and no one else. Voters in these times are overwhelmingly partisan, whether they identify as party members or as independents. Probably the Democrats in California would give their approval votes in primaries to leading Democrats, and Republicans would give their primary approval votes to leading Republicans. Because the Democratic Party is so much bigger in California than the Republican Party, that would result in two Democrats getting the most votes in the primary, and wiping Republicans (as well as minor parties and independent candidates) off the November ballot for the statewide offices and most district offices.
Consider the case of CA-4 where 14-term septuagenarian Mike Thompson was defeated by first time candidate Eric Jones. In previous elections Thompson would get 2/3 of the vote against a Republican candidate who must have known they had no hope. Thompson could run on a platform of “Orange Man Bad” and easily be elected.
In this election, both candidates had to reach out to Republican voters. If you look at a counties in CA-4 that were won by Steve Hilton, they were won overwhelmingly by Jones. If we assume that Becerra votes split evenly between Thompson and Jones, then Hilton votes went overwhelmingly to Jones, by a 6:1 or 7:1 margin, with only 1/4 to 1/3 skipping the race.
In the primary for the US House, 4th district race, there were six Republicans on the ballot and two Democrats and one independent. If the Approval Voting initiative had been in effect, and assuming 40% of the primary voters leaned Republican, and assuming those Republican-leaning voters approved of all six of the Republicans, and assuming all 60% of the Democrats approved of the two Democrats, the two Democrats would have advanced to the general election. So it would have made no difference if the Approval Voting were in effect in the primary or not.