New Lawsuit Filed to Force Virginia to Hold Special Elections for Lower House of Legislature Before 2023

Virginia elects its state officers in odd years. The 2021 election used the 2010 census districts, because the 2020 census was delayed. Some Virginia voters have been trying to persuade the federal courts to order new elections for lower house of the legislature based on districts that use the 2020 census. An earlier lawsuit lost because the voter-plaintiff happened to live in a district that is under-populated according to the 2020 census, so he could not show that he had been injured.

Now a new lawsuit has been filed by a voter-plaintiff who lives in an over-populated district. Here is the Complaint in Thomas v Beals, e.d., 3:22cv-427. The case is assigned to U.S. District Court Judge David J. Novak, a Trump appointee. If the voter, Jeffrey Thomas, wins his lawsuit, the state will hold new elections before November 2023. UPDATE: see this news story.

U.S. District Court Strikes Down Florida Ban on Contributions Above $3,000 to Groups Trying to Qualify an Initiative

On June 15, U.S. District Court Judge Allen C. Winsor, a Trump appointee, struck down the Florida law that makes it illegal for someone outside Florida to contribute more than $3,000 to a committee that is trying to qualify an initiative for the ballot. ACLU of Florida v Byrd, n.d., 4:21cv-190.

Judge Winsor had earlier enjoined the original law. The original law applied the cap on contributions to all persons, regardless of where they live. After that law was enjoined, the legislature amended it so that the ban only applies to persons who live outside of Florida. But the judge said the new version is also invalid. In fact, because the original purpose for the law was supposedly to limit fraud in petitioning, the judge said the amendment makes it even more obvious that the so-called rationale is weak. Here is the decision. Thanks to Mike Drucker for this news.

New York Daily News Editorial Condemns Law that Eliminated the Qualified Status of the Libertarian, Green, and SAM Parties

The New York Daily News has this editorial on New York election laws. Toward the bottom, it condemns the 2020 law that made it far more difficult for parties to become and remain qualified. The editorial specifically says the SAM, Green, and Libertarian Parties belong on the ballot. However, it celebrates that recent bill that makes it illegal for parties to have “Independence” or “Independent” as part of their names. Thanks to Fairvote for the link.

It is unfortunate that the New York Times has not editorialized about these issues.