Eric Esshaki, Plaintiff in Michigan Ballot Access Lawsuit, Explains Why He Had More Signatures than Stated in His Lawsuit

As already reported, a U.S. District Court Judge cut the number of signatures for Michigan primary candidates early this week, and then the state filed a request for reconsideration, saying he didn’t really need the relief, so the decision should be altered to no longer cut the number of signatures.  The state said it knows he didn’t need the relief because he turned in approximately 1,200 signatures.

On April 24, the lead plaintiff, Eric Esshaki, who needed 1,000 signatures to get on the Republican primary ballot for U.S. House, filed a court document explaining that after he won the lawsuit, that got him so much publicity that many voters filled out the petition blank he had postally sent them and returned it to him.  So, when he submitted his petition, it had more signatures than he had expected.  Here is his interesting statement.  Many of the signatures returned to him were put in his home mailbox by persons driving by to help him, rather than going through the postal mail.  Unfortunately many of the signatures were invalid because people signed the petition as voters, but then didn’t fill out the bottom of the petition saying they were also the circulators.

Connecticut Libertarian Party Files Federal Lawsuit over Petition Requirements

On April 4, the Connecticut Libertarian Party filed a federal lawsuit over ballot access and other election law problems.  Libertarian Party of Connecticut v Merrill, 3:20cv-467.  It is assigned to U.S. District Court Janet C. Hall, a Clinton appointee who earlier had struck down the ban on out-of-state circulators.  Here is the Complaint.

In late March, the Connecticut Secretary of State had recommended that if a party is on the ballot for one statewide race, then for 2020 it should be deemed to be qualified for all partisan office.  But only the Governor can implement this idea, and so far he has refused to respond to the Secretary of State’s suggestion.  If he had accepted the Secretary’s idea, the Libertarian Party would not have needed to petition in 2020, because it polled over 1% for President in 2016 and also polled over 1% for Treasurer.

The lawsuit had a hearing on April 20, and the state agreed to settlement talks, which will be complete by May 4.  The lawsuit does not just challenge the need to petition in 2020, but in all years.  It also attacks the state law that says parties that received over 20% for Governor are listed on the voter registration form, but other qualified parties are not listed, and an applicant must write them in on the form.

News Story on April 23 Michigan Ballot Access Hearing

On April 23, U.S. District Court Judge Terrence G. Berg held another hearing in Esshaki v Whitmer, the case over whether primary petition signature requirements should be lowered.  Judge Berg had already cut the number of signatures down to 50%, but the state objected and asked for a rehearing, which was held.  See this news story.  A decision will be out by Friday afternoon, April 24.

Rumors Circulate About Late-Announcing Presidential Candidates for Libertarian and Green Parties

There are unconfirmed rumors that Congressman Justin Amash has become a dues-paying life member of the Libertarian Party and that he will seek the party’s presidential nomination.  There are also rumors that former Minnesota Governor Jesse Ventura may seek the Green Party presidential nomination.

The last time that either the Democratic Party or the Republican Party nominated someone for president who had not declared as late as April of the election year was 1952, when the Democratic Party nominated Adlai Stevenson at its July 21-26 convention.  He had not desired to be a presidential candidate, and had said so clearly.  But he gave the welcoming speech at the Democratic Chicago convention, because he was the host Governor, and his speech was received so well, delegates insisted that he run.  He did not want to run against General Dwight Eisenhower, but at the convention he agreed to do so.