California Top-Two System Leaves Democrats With No Candidate in a Legislative Race that Democrats Won in 2018

At the March 3, 2020 primary, California’s 38th Assembly District had no incumbent running. Five Democrats and two Republicans filed. The two Republicans placed first and second, even though in the 2018 election, Democrats had won the seat.

The seat is in northern Los Angeles County.

The top-two system began in California in 2011. This is only the second time Democrats have been left without a candidate in the general election, in a district that the Democratic Party had won in the previous election. The first instance was in 2012, in the 31st U.S. House district.

Republicans suffered from this type of anomaly in 2018 in the 76th Assembly distrrict.

Virginia Bill, Ending Ability of Office-Holders to Dictate Party Nomination Method, Dies in Senate

Virginia SB 126 did not pass, and the legislature has now adjourned. It would have repealed the law that lets incumbents dictate to their party which nomination method should be used for that particular office, convention or primary. The law was held unconstitutional last year by the Fourth Circuit, but it will remain on the books, even though it has no force.