Libertarian Party and Constitution Party File Lawsuit Against New South Dakota March 1 Petition Deadline

Earlier this year South Dakota changed the petition deadline for a newly-qualifying party to submit a petition of 2.5% of the last gubernatorial vote for party status. The old deadline was March 29. The new deadline is March 1. On June 15, the Libertarian Party and the Constitution Party filed a lawsuit against that deadline, Libertarian Party of South Dakota v Krebs, 4:15-cv-4111.

South Dakota is in the Eighth Circuit. In 1977 the Eighth Circuit said in MacBride v Exon, 558 F 2d 443, “It is completely unreasonable and unrealistic for a state to provide by statute that a person cannot get his name on the state’s presidential ballot as a third party candidate unless that party has qualified as a party in advance of primary elections.” Currently, South Dakota is the only state in which it is impossible for a new party to appear on the November ballot with a presidential candidate and the party label, unless that party participates in a primary. The South Dakota primary is in early June. MacBride v Exon was a Nebraska case, and the Nebraska primary was (and still is) in May.

UPDATE: here is a news story about the lawsuit.

Two Law Professors Publish Paper on Struggle for Power within Republican Party between Official Party Officers and Wealthy Individuals who Aren’t Party Officers

Law Professors Joseph Fishkin and Heather Gerkin have published a scholarly paper on the current status of the national Republican Party, in which the official party structure and the Koch Brothers each have their own database of Republican Party donors, activists, and voters. The Koch Brothers’ database is superior to the party’s database. Fishkin and Gerkin conceive of the Koch Brothers as part of the national Republican Party, despite their lack of office within the party. Their paper explores the ramifications of this split between the formal party structure and the party’s influential backers. Thanks to Rick Hasen for the link.

U.S. Supreme Court Issues Three Opinions, None of them Relating to Election Law or First Amendment

On June 15, the U.S. Supreme Court released three opinions, but did not release any opinions relating to election law or the First Amendment. The only two remaining days for U.S. Supreme Court decisions for this term are June 22 and June 29. UPDATE: there will also probably be decisions on Thursday, June 18. Thanks to Thomas Jones for that update.