Globe & Mail Carries Analysis of How Proportional Representation Would Have Worked in Canada’s 2025 Election

The Globe & Mail has this interesting analysis of Canada’s 2025 election, and how the outcome would have been if Canada uses proportional representation. The story also has a map showing how each constituency voted. As in the U.S., there is a strong split between urban and rural areas. The analysis advocates in favor of proportional representation.

Florida Legislature Passes Bill Restricting Who Can Circulate Initiative Petitions

On May 1, the Florida legislature passed CS/HB 1205. It says that no one may circulate an initiative petition to more than five voters plus family member voters who live with the circulator, unless the circulator has taken a two-hour on-line course. See this story.

It also imposes fines of $2,500 on anyone who circulates but who doesn’t submit the petitions within ten days after they had been signed.

Maine Legislator Asks U.S. Supreme Court to Restore Her Ability to Cast Votes in the Legislature

A Maine state representative, Laurel D. Libby, has asked the U.S. Supreme Court to restore her ability to cast votes in the legislature. She lost the ability to vote in late February 2025, because she refuses to apologize for her statements about the issue of whether it is fair to let transgender women compete in high school sports. Libby then sued the Speaker of the Maine House so that she can again vote, but she lost in U.S. District Court and in the First Circuit.

Her U.S. Supreme Court filing is here, and was filed on April 28. Today the Court asked for a response. The case is Libby v Fecteau, 24A1051.

Sixth Circuit Upholds Tennessee Ballot Access Law for New Political Parties

On May 1, the Sixth Circuit issued a nine-page opinion, upholding the Tennessee law that requires 43,498 signatures for a new or previously unqualified party to get on the Tennessee ballot. Darnell v Hargett, 24-5856.

The opinion is by Judge Chad Readler, a Trump appointee. It is also signed by Judge Amul Thapar, another Trump appointee; and Eric Clay, a Clinton appointee. It will not be published.

It merely says that the law has been upheld before. It does not mention that since then, the Sixth Circuit struck down Michigan’s 30,000-signature requirement for independent statewide candidates. Nor does it mention that the Tennessee law has existed since 1972 and has never been used. It doesn’t mention any U.S. Supreme Court ballot access opinion.