Fourth Circuit Sets Approximate Date for Oral Argument in North Carolina Ballot Access Case

The Fourth Circuit had tentatively set the oral argument date in Pisano v Strach, 13-1368, for the period October 29-November 1. This is the case that challenges the May petition deadline for newly-qualifying parties to submit their 90,000 valid signatures. The U.S. District Court had refused to allow the plaintiffs to engage in discovery to see if the state really has any valid interest in this deadline. The U.S. District Court had dismissed the case with a short opinion, which seemed to combine an attitude that the plaintiffs don’t have standing, and a blanket assertion that any state ballot access regulation is automatically constitutional.

Back in 1988, the North Carolina State Board of Elections was so convinced that the May deadline was unconstitutional, it waived the deadline and let the New Alliance Party submit its petition in July. Newly-qualifying parties in North Carolina nominate by convention, so there is no reason to have the deadline as early as May. In the past, the North Carolina petition deadline for newly-qualifying parties was in August. It was moved to July in 1949, and to May in 1979.

Green Party Gains a Partisan Office-Holder in West Virginia

On July 24, 2012, Charleston, West Virginia city councilwoman Kasey Russell revealed that she has changed her registration from “Democrat” to “Mountain .” In West Virginia, the name of the state Green Party is the Mountain Party. It has been ballot-qualified starting since November 2000. Charleston City Council is a partisan body. The council now has fifteen Democrats, eleven Republicans, and one Green Party member. See this story. As far as is known, this is the first time any member of a minor party has held partisan office in West Virginia since the Prohibition Party elected a state legislator in 1906. Thanks to Andrew for the link.

Tenth Circuit Sets Argument Date in Case Challenging Unequal Contribution Limits in Colorado

The Tenth Circuit will hear oral arguments in Riddle v Hickenlooper, 13-1108, on September 26, 2013, at 9 a.m., in Denver. This is the case that challenges unequal contribution limits in Colorado. Colorado law says an individual may donate $400 to a legislative candidate who is nominated in a primary, but only $200 to a legislative candidate who is nominated by convention (i.e., a typical minor party candidate), or by petition (i.e., an independent candidate), or a write-in candidate.

The U.S. District Court had upheld the unequal contribution limits, even though the U.S. Supreme Court in Davis v Federal Election Commission ruled that unequal contribution limits for all candidates for a particular office are unconstitutional.

This particular case was filed on behalf of Joelle Riddle, who wanted to donate $400 to Kathleen Curry, a write-in candidate in 2010. Curry was a viable candidate, who wanted to be on the ballot as an independent, but a restrictive Colorado ballot access law kept her off the ballot because she had too recently been a registered Democrat. She was the incumbent.

July 2013 Ballot Access News Print Edition

Ballot Access News
July 1, 2013 – Volume 29, Number 2

This issue was printed on green paper.


Table of Contents

  1. MINOR PARTIES WIN THREE BALLOT ACCESS SUITS
  2. ARIZONA PASSES NEW BALLOT ACCESS BARRIER
  3. OREGON EASES BALLOT ACCESS BARRIER
  4. CALIFORNIA ASSEMBLY DEFEATS BALLOT ACCESS RESTRICTION
  5. HAWAII DEMOCRATS SUE TO OBTAIN CLOSED PRIMARY
  6. KANSAS RE-INTERPRETS LAW TO MAKE BALLOT ACCESS HARDER
  7. SEVENTH CIRCUIT UPHOLDS ILLINOIS BALLOT ACCESS LAW
  8. RHODE ISLAND PASSES NATIONAL POPULAR VOTE PLAN BILL
  9. LIBERTARIAN MICHIGAN LAWSUIT
  10. BOOK REVIEWS: RESURRECTING DEMOCRACY and THE CENTRIST MANIFESTO
  11. 2014 PETITIONING FOR STATEWIDE OFFICE
  12. PRESIDENT OBAMA MENTIONS GREEN, LIBERTARIAN PARTIES IN SPEECH
  13. NADER 2004 BALLOT ACCESS LAWSUITS ARE FINALLY ENDED
  14. LIBERTARIAN PARTY GAINS A PARTISAN OFFICE-HOLDER
  15. SPECIAL ELECTION RETURNS
  16. RHODE ISLAND GOVERNOR SWITCHES FROM INDEPENDENT TO DEMOCRAT
  17. NEW JERSEY SOCIALIST PARTY SUES TO GAIN REGISTRATION RIGHTS
  18. SUBSCRIBING TO BAN WITH PAYPAL