Reply Brief Filed in New York Ballot Label Lawsuit

On April 15, Jim Walden, the New York city mayoral candidate who wants “Independence” as his ballot label, filed this reply brief in Walder v Kosinski, 25-764.

In 2022 the New York legislature banned the words “Independence” and “independent” from ever being part of a qualified party’s name. Election officials therefore won’t even permit an independent candidate to use either of those words in his or her ballot label. New York is one of the 25 states that lets an independent candidate choose a party label that is not too long and not obscene. But this interpretation of the 2022 law means that a New York independent candidate can’t even have the word “independent” as a ballot label, which is absurd.

New York Ban on Out-of-State Circulators Was Finally Declared Unconstitutional in September 2024

This is old news, but BAN hadn’t reported it. On September 17, 2024, U.S. District Court Judge Brian M. Cogan, a Bush Jr. appointee, struck down the New York ban on out-of-state circulators. The same judge had enjoined it in 2022, in a Libertarian lawsuit, Schmidt v Kosinski, e.d., 1:22cv-2210. Here is the four-page order.