Hawaii Filing Closes; Most Minor Party Candidates Since Statehood

Hawaii primary filing closed on July 3. This year, there are 21 candidates running in minor party primaries, the greatest number since statehood in 1959. All minor parties in Hawaii nominate all of their candidates in the August 9 primary. There are also eleven independent candidates.

The minor party candidates include sixteen Libertarians, three from the Independent Party (a new party formed this year), and two Greens. One of the Greens is Keiko Bonk, who is again running for the State House against the Democratic speaker, Calvin Say. In 2012 Bonk received 3,143 votes; Say received 5,704 votes; and the Republican nominee placed third with 1,179. The November 2012 election in this district was marred when polling places in areas in which Bonk was strongest ran out of ballots.

The Libertarian Party hopes to poll enough votes with its legislative candidates to retain its place on the ballot in 2016. In 1999 the law was changed, to provide that if a party polls for its legislative candidates a number of votes that equals 2% of all the votes cast in all legislative races, then it remains on the ballot. There are 64 legislative races up this year, and Libertarians are running in twelve of them. In five of the races, the Libertarian will be in a two-candidate race in November, and so there is a reasonable chance that the Libertarian Party will be the first minor party to retain its spot on the ballot via the 1999 “2%” amendment.

It is difficult to predict how many independent candidates will be on the ballot in November. Hawaii treats independent candidates (for office other than President) very severely. They can’t be on the November ballot unless they poll the lesser of: (1) 10% of the primary vote for that office; or (2) a number of votes that exceeds a partisan primary winner in that same race. Typically independent candidates have no chance of getting on the November ballot unless they are lucky enough to be running in a race in which a minor party person is also running, because few voters typically choose a minor party primary ballot, so the independent hopes there is a minor party entry in the race. Thanks to Bob Johnston for the news about the Hawaii candidate list.

Top-Two System Again Excludes All Minor Parties from General Election Campaign if At Least Two Major Party Members Ran

On June 3, California held a top-two primary for Congress and partisan state office. All 25 minor party candidates who were on the ballot failed to place first or second. As a result, in all U.S. history, there have now been 111 instances in which a minor party member ran for Congress or partisan state office in a top-two system (in elections in which there were at least two major party candidates also running). In all 111 instances, the minor party member did not place first or second and was therefore barred from the general election ballot.

There will be at least three minor party members on the California November ballot, but all three (and conceivably even a few more) ran in races with only one major party member running in the same race. All three of the minor party candidates were write-in candidates in June, and since only one write-in filed in each of these three races, the three minor party candidates cannot fail to place second (assuming the candidate receives at least one write-in vote; write-ins haven’t been counted yet).

Independent for U.S. House Qualifies in Maine, for First Time Since 2006

Blaine Richardson has qualified for the Maine general election ballot, as an independent candidate for U.S. House, 2nd district. Also, Richard Murphy has qualified as an independent for U.S. House, 1st district. They are the first non-major party candidates to be on the Maine general election ballot for U.S. House since 2006.

Maine and Georgia were the only states with a Democratic-Republican monopoly for U.S. House during the entire period 2008 through 2012. Thanks to Tom MacMillan for this news.

Technological Errors Result in Artificial Increase in Green Party “Membership” in Lucas County, Ohio

Ohio voter registration forms don’t ask voters to choose a party. Yet the state tries to determine the party membership of voters, based on their choice of a primary ballot at the polls on election day. According to this story, many voters who did not choose a Green Party primary ballot last month still were recorded as though they had, due to problems with technology.

Albany Times-Union Editorializes in Favor of More Than Two Candidates in New York General Election Gubernatorial Debates

The Albany Times-Union has this editorial, saying that Howie Hawkins, Green Party candidate for Governor of New York, should be allowed to debate Andrew Cuomo and the Republican nominee for Governor of New York, Rob Astorino. The editorial writer seems to feel that no one else should be allowed into the debate, although it is premature to make that determination until everyone knows who is on the ballot. The petition for unqualified party nominees is not due until August 5.