Tennessee Democratic Party Disavows its own U.S. Senate Nominee

Tennessee major parties held their primaries on Thursday, August 2. The surprise winner of the Democratic Party primary winner is Mark E. Clayton, a floor finisher who did not campaign and whose issue stances are completely at odds with the Democratic Party. See this story about the primary.

The unofficial vote totals are: Mark Clayton 48,126; Gary Gene Davis 24,789; Park Overall 24,263; Larry Crim 17,383; Benjamin Roberts 16,369; Dave Handock 16,167; T. K. Owens 13,366. The total turnout, only 160,463 votes, is quite low, although Democratic primaries in Tennessee typically have low turnout in August. In 2008 only 183,348 voters voted in the U.S. Senate primary in August, although the 2008 Democratic presidential primary in February had 624,764 voters.

On August 3, the Democratic Party formally disavowed Clayton and said it might seek court action to replace him as the nominee. See this story. Whether a party can do that in Tennessee is still unsettled. The 6th circuit heard a somewhat similar case from Tennessee on January 17, 2012, and still has not handed down its decision. The U.S. District Court in that case, Kurita v The State Primary Board of the Democratic Party, said a party can replace a primary nominee with someone else.

Tennessee has open primaries. The Green Party, the Constitution Party, and the Libertarian Party, all have U.S. Senate nominees in Tennessee this year. However, the Tennessee Elections office so far refuses to list the Green Party nominee and the Constitution Party nominee on its web page, even though in February a U.S. District Court put those parties on the ballot and they certified their nominees. Thanks to Bill Van Allen for this news.

Shawn Steel Article Describes Instance at Which California Top-Two System Adherents Tried and Failed to Unseat a Conservative Republican Legislator

Shawn Steel, a former California Republican Party chair, has this interesting account of the California June 2012 outcome for the 74th Assembly District. The incumbent, who was the more conservative of the two Republicans running, placed first, and a second candidate, a Democrat, placed second, so they will be the only two candidates in November. The third candidate, the recipient of hundreds of thousands of dollars in campaign assistance from adherents of the top-two primary system, only polled 23% and came in third.

Prominent Civic Leader in Springfield, Illinois, Who Tried to be an Independent Candidate for Legislature, Challenged Off the Ballot

According to this story, Bob Gray’s petition to be on the ballot for State Senate in the Illinois 50th district was challenged, and he does not have quite enough valid signatures to appear on the November ballot. This development leaves only one candidate, the Republican nominee, on the November ballot.

Gray is the President of the Springfield Citizens Club, a civic organization that sponsors lectures on matters of public interest. In 2009 he received the State Journal-Register’s “First Citizen” Award.

Illinois requires independent candidates for district office to submit a petition of 5% of the last vote cast, except that in years after redistricting, the requirement for State Senate is a flat 3,000 signatures.

New York Legislative Candidate Wins Legal Fight over Residency, Even Though he was Registered to Vote in Massachusetts

On August 3, Patrick Manning won a lawsuit in New York Supreme Court, retaining his spot on the Republican primary ballot as a candidate for Assembly. New York requires legislative candidates to have lived in New York for the preceding five years. Manning’s ballot status was challenged on the grounds that he had been registered to vote at his vacation home in Massachusetts during that period. However, the Court found that Manning was a resident of New York during the entire period. See this story. Thanks to Bill Van Allen for the link.