On February 16, the New Jersey Supreme Court issued an opinion in In re: Contest of November 8, 2011 General Election of Office of the New Jersey General Assembly, A58-11. By a vote of 4-3, the Court upheld a challenge to the eligibility of Gabriela Mosquera to be seated in the lower house of the legislature, because she had not lived in the district for a full year. The New Jersey Constitution requires candidates for the legislature to meet that duration of residency requirement. Mosquera argued that the New Jersey Constitution violates the U.S. Constitution, but that argument did not prevail.
Mosquera, a Democratic Party nominee, won the election last November, and she wasn’t challenged until after the election. However, by now she has lived in the district a full year. When a legislative seat is vacant in New Jersey, that seat is filled by the party that won the last election for that seat. The Democratic Party is expected to appoint her to fill the vacancy. She will then be required to run in November, 2012, to retain her seat.