U.S. House Signature Requirements for Minor Party and Independent Candidates in Illinois and Pennsylvania are Significantly Lower This Year than Normally

Because 2012 is the first election year following redistricting, the number of signatures needed for minor party and independent candidates for U.S. House in Illinois and Pennsylvania is significantly lower than in normal years.

In Illinois, in a normal year, the petition is 5% of the last vote cast. That means the typical U.S. House district following a presidential year needs, on the average, 14,000 signatures; and following a midterm year, 10,000. But Illinois law says in the year after redistricting, the requirement is exactly 5,000 signatures.

In Pennsylvania, in a normal year, the U.S. House petition is 2% of the winning candidate’s vote in the last election. But in years after redistricting, the new districts didn’t exist in the last election. So, instead, the state uses a different base for the percentage. Instead of 2% of the winner for Congress two years previously, it calculates what the winner of the preceding odd-year judicial election received in the new district. This is a lot of work for election officials. It also means that because the turnout is so much lower in the odd-year election years, the calculation produces a lower number. In 2012, in the average U.S. House district in Pennsylvania, an independent, or the nominee of an unqualified party, needs 1,144 signatures. By contrast, in 2010 the requirement in the average district was 3,842 signatures. Thanks to John Murphy for this news. UPDATE: it turns out that another clause in the Pennsylvania election law requires minor party and independent candidate requirements to never be less than what Democrats and Republicans need to get on the primary ballot. That number for major party members is 1,000 signatures to run for U.S. House, so this year minor party and independent candidates need between 1,000 and 1,961 signatures, depending on which district the candidate is running in.

Green Party and Constitution Party Respond to Tennessee’s Efforts to Remove them from Ballot

On April 10, the Constitution Party of Tennessee, and the Green Party of Tennessee, filed this brief in the 6th circuit. The state is trying to persuade the 6th Circuit to remove these two parties from the 2012 ballot. A U.S. District Court had put them on, on February 3, 2012. The state says the two parties haven’t shown a modicum of voter support.

U.S. District Court Refuses to Reconsider Decision in Nader v Federal Election Commission

On April 12, U.S. District Court Judge Royce Lamberth issued this 12-page order in Nader v Federal Election Commission, 1:10cv989. Nader had filed the case in 2010, arguing that the FEC was wrong to have dismissed his complaint against the Democratic Party for spending millions of dollars in 2004 to keep him off the ballot, and then failing to report these expenditures. Nader couldn’t file the case earlier than 2010 because it took the FEC so long to dismiss Nader’s complaint.

On November 9, 2011, Judge Lamberth had dismissed Nader’s lawsuit against the FEC. On December 9, Nader had asked him to reconsider. Judge Lamberth won’t reconsider, but it is noteworthy that he wrote such a lengthy explanation defending his original decision. Nader will appeal to the U.S. Court of Appeals.

History News Network Carries Two Op-Eds on Americans Elect

The History News Network is a ten-year-old forum for historians. The purpose of the site is to carry articles by historians that help put current events into historical perspective. Recently the Network carried two op-eds about Americans Elect. Here is the first submission, by Robert Brent Toplin, which ran on March 26. Here is a somewhat different perspective, by J. David Gillespie, which ran on April 9.

Wisconsin Says Americans Elect Petition is Valid

On April 12, Wisconsin state election officials determined that the Americans Elect petition has enough valid signatures. The state requires 10,000, and Americans Elect had submitted 17,000. Wisconsin now has four qualified parties. The others are Republican, Democratic, and Constitution.

Groups that are not qualified parties can still place nominees on the November ballot, with the party label, if they file independent candidate petitions. The independent petition for statewide nominees is 2,000 signatures.