Maine Lawsuit on Anonymous Bloggers Involved with Campaigns Makes News

In 2010, an anonymous blog came into existence in Maine, in connection with the gubernatorial general election. The web site, called “The Cutler Files”, posted derogatory information about Eliot Cutler, an independent candidate for Governor who was almost elected. Later, the Maine Commission on Governmental Ethics fined the blogger, Dennis Bailey, $200 for failing to disclose that he was the author of the blog. Bailey then sued the Commission, arguing that the U.S. Constitution protects anonymous speech about political campaigns. He filed his lawsuit in state court, but it was quickly removed to federal court. In federal court, the case is Bailey v State of Maine Commission on Government Ethics, 1:11-cv-00179-JAW.

The case is far from being resolved. However, on December 19, the federal magistrate hearing the case ruled that certain confidential documents and e-mails involved in the case may be made public. These include evidence that the blogger was working with one of the Democratic candidates for Governor, Rosa Scarcelli, when he set up the blog. See this story.

Link to the Texas Secretary of State’s Form for Unqualified Parties to Notify the State that they Intend to Petition in 2012

Texas has a unique law which requires parties that intend to qualify by petition to notify the state that they intend to do that. The intention form is due January 2, 2012. Here is a link to the form.

The requirement discriminates against parties that are formed in the spring of election years, because by then it is too late to complete the form. If Texas had had a law like this in 1912, Theodore Roosevelt could not have put his new Progressive Party on the ballot, because even the idea for the party did not occur to Roosevelt until after Roosevelt failed to get the Republican presidential nomination in June 1912. Similarly, Strom Thurmond and his States Rights Party did get on the ballot in Texas in 1948, because Texas did not have this law back then. Thurmond’s party was not created until July 1948.

The law was passed in 1993 and has never been challenged in court. There is no election administration-related need for the form, because a party can’t begin to petition until after the primary anyway. in 2012 a party can’t begin to petition until April. If a new party were formed in the spring of 2012 that had not existed as of January 2, 2012, it would seem to be in a position to challenge the law, especially as applied to a presidential election.

The last time that a new party was formed in the United States in the election year itself, and which proved to have a fairly strong ability to get on ballots, was the Natural Law Party. It was formed in April 1992. Of course, the Texas law didn’t exist that year. Since the formation of the Natural Law Party in 1992, all the new parties formed in the U.S., and which had any heft, have been formed in the odd years before the election.

Libertarian Party News for December 2011 of Special Interest for Those Interested in History

The Libertarian Party News, December 2011 issue, is especially interesting for those interested in political history. The 16-page issue has a compilation by Arthur DiBianca showing instances when Libertarian Party nominees in partisan elections either won, or out-polled one of their major party opponents. The issue also has an extensive summary of Libertarian Party history, by calendar year. This historical emphasis is to mark the party’s anniversary, of 40 years of existence.

The only other nationally-organized political parties in the United States that have existed for at least 40 years, and which were electorally active for at least that long, have been these parties: Prohibition, Socialist Labor, Socialist, Communist, and Socialist Workers.

Americans Elect Eases Rules on Who Can Run in American Elect’s Presidential Primary

Americans Elect has eased several rules on how candidates may seek the group’s presidential nomination. The original rules said that “automatic” candidates need 10,000 clicks, and “contingent” candidates need 100,000 clicks. “Clicks” means a computer response from a delegate, sitting at home in front of his or her computer. In effect, a “click” is a vote. The original rules said all these clicks must come in during a one-month period.

The new, more relaxed rules say that the clicks may come in at any time, from the moment the candidate declares for the nomination, through April 3. The new rules also lower the “contingent” candidate requirement from 100,000 to 50,000.

As before, “automatic” means someone who has the objective characteristics of past Presidents…a past or present member of Congress, or a past or present Governor, or a past or present cabinet member, or past high-ranking general, or CEO of a very large business, or national leader of a major labor union.

Americans Elect also relaxed the rules on how the delegates may override any rules-related decision of the Americans Elect board. The old rules required 2/3rds of the delegates to vote to overrule the Board. The new rules require a majority vote, and expand the time period during which the delegates may participate in an override vote.

Americans Elect held a press conference on December 21 to announce the new rules. During the question-and-answer period, Americans Elect leaders engaged in a vigorous debate with some reporters who have criticized Americans Elect because not all donors to Americans Elect are publicly identified.

Public Policy Poll Results for Seven Theoretical 3-Way Presidential Races

On December 20, Public Policy Polling released these results concerning the presidential election. Questions 12 through 18 ask voters how they would vote if confronted with seven different three-way general election choices. For all seven, the assumption is that Mitt Romney will be the Republican nominee.

The seven “other” candidates tested, and their percentages, were: Donald Trump 19%, Ron Paul 17%, Jon Huntsman 11%, Gary Johnson 9%, Mike Bloomberg 8%, Bernie Sanders 7%, and Rocky Anderson 4%. Thanks to Independent Political Report for the link.