Slate Carries Analysis, "Should Specter Have Run as an Independent?"

Last year, U.S. Senator Arlen Specter of Pennsylvania changed his registration from Republican to Democratic, after he and others in Pennsylvania realized that he would probably lose the May 18, 2010 Republican primary.

Now, however, he is trailing in the Democratic primary. Slate has this interesting article by Steve Kornacki, asking whether Specter would have been wise to change his registration last year from Republican to independent, and to have run for re-election this year as an independent.

Ironically, in 1997, Specter tried to make Pennsylvania ballot access far more difficult. He used his influence with Pennsylvania Republican legislators (who were in the majority in both houses) to get a bill through the legislature, quadrupling the number of signatures for independent and minor party candidates. The bill passed, but fortunately Governor Tom Ridge vetoed it.

The reason Specter tried to make ballot access for independents and minor parties more difficult back in 1997 is because he was up for re-election as a Republican in 1998, and he hoped to prevent the Constitution Party from getting a candidate on the ballot against him. Specter has always been pro-choice, and he had seen how well the Constitution Party had polled in the 1994 Pennsylvania governor’s race, when the Republican Party nominee for Governor had also been pro-choice. As things turned out, Specter was overwhelmingly re-elected as a Republican in 1998. Although the Constitution Party did get on the ballot against him, it only polled 68,377 votes.

Colorado Ballot Access Bill Moves Ahead

On May 10, the Colorado Senate passed HB 1271 on second reading, by a vote of 19-16. The Senate also amended it so that it takes effect immediately. The House had already passed the bill. But because the Senate amended it, it must go back to the House, and the legislature is almost ready to adjourn for the year. See this story in the Durango Herald.

HB 1271 is the bill that relaxes the prior disaffiliation law for independent candidates. Current law says an independent candidate cannot get on the ballot if the person had been registered into a qualified party at any time during the previous year before filing. The bill changes the disaffiliation rule, so that it only applies if the independent candidate had been a member of a qualified party during the election year.

Republican Legislative Candidates Begin Dropping out of Washington State Legislative Race, as a Consequence of “Top-Two” System

The interesting saga of Washington state’s legislative race in the 18(1) district continues. See this earlier coverage, which revealed that the Republican incumbent is not running for re-election this year. Six Republicans jumped into the race. Then the Republican Party realized that even though this is a district that usually votes 60% Republican, that large field of Republicans in the primary would be bad for the party’s chances of holding the seat this year.

This is because Washington state uses a top-two system. With only two Democrats running in the primary in this district, and six strong Republicans in the primary, the odds were high that two Democrats would place first and second. Now, two of the Republicans have dropped out, even though the primary is not until August 17. Clearly, Republican Party officials have been working to narrow the field. Of course, this development means fewer choices in the primary for Republicans. See this story about the latest developments. Thanks to Dan Meek for the link.

Republican Legislative Candidates Begin Dropping out of Washington State Legislative Race, as a Consequence of "Top-Two" System

The interesting saga of Washington state’s legislative race in the 18(1) district continues. See this earlier coverage, which revealed that the Republican incumbent is not running for re-election this year. Six Republicans jumped into the race. Then the Republican Party realized that even though this is a district that usually votes 60% Republican, that large field of Republicans in the primary would be bad for the party’s chances of holding the seat this year.

This is because Washington state uses a top-two system. With only two Democrats running in the primary in this district, and six strong Republicans in the primary, the odds were high that two Democrats would place first and second. Now, two of the Republicans have dropped out, even though the primary is not until August 17. Clearly, Republican Party officials have been working to narrow the field. Of course, this development means fewer choices in the primary for Republicans. See this story about the latest developments. Thanks to Dan Meek for the link.