Florida Bills Advance, Would Outlaw Paying Per Signature

The Florida bills to make it illegal to pay petition circulators on a per-signature basis (for initiatives) have cleared all committees. S956 passed the Senate Ethics and Elections Committee on April 16, and the identical CS/HB497 passed the House Economic Development Council on April 17. The bills include many other provisions as well, and are each 81 pages. Yet the committees only allowed a few minutes of testimony. Already the bill is receiving criticism; see this editorial from St. Petersburg’s daily newspaper, the Petersburg Times, April 19 issue. Thanks to Rick Hasen for that editorial link.

Independence Party of New York's Hudson Valley Tries to Systemize Nomination Decisions

The Independence Party in the Hudson Valley region of New York is trying to regularize and systemize decisions on which major party candidates to cross-endorse. The Independence Party organizations in Orange, Ulster, Sullivan and Dutchess Counties have a specific platform, concerning local and state government issues. The four county parties will endeavor to only cross-endorse Republican or Democratic nominees whose views reflect the Independence Party’s local platform. For more information, see this story in the Times Herald-Record of Middletown, New York, published April 18. Thanks to Bill Van Allen for the link.

Independence Party of New York’s Hudson Valley Tries to Systemize Nomination Decisions

The Independence Party in the Hudson Valley region of New York is trying to regularize and systemize decisions on which major party candidates to cross-endorse. The Independence Party organizations in Orange, Ulster, Sullivan and Dutchess Counties have a specific platform, concerning local and state government issues. The four county parties will endeavor to only cross-endorse Republican or Democratic nominees whose views reflect the Independence Party’s local platform. For more information, see this story in the Times Herald-Record of Middletown, New York, published April 18. Thanks to Bill Van Allen for the link.

New York Finishes Counting Non-challenged Ballots in US House Special Election; Democrat Leading

On April 17, the last unchallenged ballots were counted in New York’s special election for U.S. House, 20th district. Democratic-Working Families-Independence nominee Scott Murphy leads Republican-Conservative nominee James Tedisco by 273 votes. However, there are still approximately 1,200 challenged ballots to be disposed of.

A pattern has developed recently that when a major party challenges ballot status for a minor party or independent candidate in the same race, the challenging major party loses the election. This appears to be true in the New York election (assuming Murphy does indeed win), because Republicans and Conservatives had challenged ballot status for the Libertarian Party’s nominee Eric Sundwall (Sundwall had then endorsed Murphy).

The pattern also held up in 2008, in both Pennsylvania and Maine. In 2008, Pennsylvania Republicans unsuccessfully challenged Bob Barr’s ballot position, and McCain subsequently lost Pennsylvania. In Maine, Democratic U.S. Senate nominee Tom Allen had challenged the only independent in that race, and Allen went on to lose the election overwhelmingly.

April 23 is Key Date for Oklahoma Ballot Access Reform Bill

Oklahoma bills must pass out of both houses of the legislature by the end of the day, April 23, if they are to have a chance of being enacted. Bills that have passed both houses by that date need not be identical in both houses; there is still time after April 23 for conference committees and additional votes. The ballot access reform bill, HB 1072, will receive a vote in the Senate on or before April 23. If it passes in the Senate, then it will go to a conference committee. As amended by the Senate Committee, it lowers the number of signatures for a previously unqualified party from 5% of the last vote cast, to 3% of the last gubernatorial vote cast. Even if it passes, Oklahoma will still have the nation’s most difficult mandatory petition requirement for ballot access for parties. Although Maine, Minnesota, Rhode Island, and California have petitions higher than 3% of the last midterm vote cast, the Maine, Minnesota, Rhode Island and California petition procedures are alternative methods for qualifying a new party, not mandatory procedures.