Web Page Features Briefs from Pending Lawsuit Over Disparity in Population of U.S. House Districts

Last year, a lawsuit was filed arguing that the disparity in U.S. House districts violates the 14th amendment. Montana has one U.S. House seat and contains approximately 900,000 residents. Wyoming has one U.S. House seat and contains approximately 500,000 residents. Plaintiffs argue that “one person, one vote” principles must apply to U.S. House districts, and that Congress is constitutionally required to create greater equality in the population of U.S. House districts.

Congress could create greater equality of population either by providing that U.S. House districts need not necessarily align with state boundaries, or it could increase the number of members of the U.S. House. Plaintiffs argue that one or the other of these solutions is required. The case is Clemons v U.S. Department of Commerce, 3:09-cv-104, filed in the Northern District of Mississippi. The briefs in this interesting case are posted at www.apportionment.us. See here. The latest brief was filed in February.

The web page also includes articles about the case. The case was filed in Mississippi because Mississippi is home to some of the plaintiffs, and because Mississippi U.S. House districts are substantially more populous than the average U.S. House district. Other states that are injured include Delaware and South Dakota. Utah is also currently injured but Utah’s injury is almost certainly going to be alleviated after the 2010 census and the 2011 reapportionment.

California Green Party Creates Anti-Prop. 14 Leaflet

The California Green Party has created a leaflet that asks voters to defeat Proposition 14. See it here. Proposition is on the ballot in the June 8, 2010 election. It would provide that all candidates in congressional and state elections would run on a single primary ballot in June. Afterwards, the only two candidates permitted to run would be the two individuals who got the most votes in June.

COFOE Posts Annual Meeting Minutes on Web Page

The Coalition for Free and Open Elections has posted the minutes of its annual meeting at www.cofoe.org. That annual meeting was on February 28, 2010, in New York city.

The Coalition for Free and Open Elections has existed since 1985. It is a loose coalition of most of the nation’s nationally-organized minor parties, as well as some other organizations which support the organization’s goal of a better legal environment for minor parties and independent candidates. Thanks to COFOE webmaster Kevin Murphy for this news.

Thomas L. Friedman, Noted New York Times Columnist, Recommends Instant Runoff Voting

The print edition of the New York Times for March 24 has this Thomas L. Friedman column, recommending that states pass Instant Runoff Voting, and also recommending that states create nonpartisan commissions to draw congressional and legislative district boundaries.

Friedman cites the work of Larry Diamond, author of “The Spirit of Democracy: The Struggle to Build Free Societies Throughout the World”, and coordinator of the democracy program of the Center on Democracy, Development and the Rule of Law.” Diamond is a Stanford senior fellow.

Friedman says that if states used IRV, centrist moderates would have a better chance of being elected as independent or minor party candidates. Thanks to Carter Momberger for the link.

Hartford Courant Article on Status of Changing Connecticut’s Public Funding Law

The March 23 issue of the Hartford Courant has this article about the legislature’s plans for changing the state’s public funding law. Although the Joint Government Administration and Elections Committee passed bills six days ago that remove the discriminatory parts of the law, those bills haven’t yet received a vote on the floor of either house. Thanks to Eric Brown’s Political Activity Law for the link.