Other Nationally-Organized Minor Parties in 2006 U.S. House Races

The Reform Party only had six candidates for U.S. House, but they polled 51,877 votes. The total was boosted by the showing of the party’s nominee in Colorado’s 4th district, Eric Eidsness. He polled 11.33%, the best showing for any U.S. House nominee of a nationally-organized party, in a race with both a Democrat and a Republican. Eidsness was helped by the fact that so many Republicans dislike incumbent Marilyn Musgrave. However, she was re-elected, although she polled less than 50% of the vote.

The Socialist Workers Party only had three candidates for the U.S. House on ballots, but they polled 16,809. This is the highest SWP total for U.S. House since 1998. The Socialist Workers Party is the only nationally-organized minor party that polled more votes for U.S. House in 2006 than it had in 2004. Even the Democratic Party polled fewer votes in 2006 than in 2004 (despite its greater number of victories), because turnout in 2006 was only about two-thirds of 2004 turnout.

The only other nationally-organized minor party with U.S. House candidates this year, not mentioned so far during posts of the last two days, is the Socialist Equality Party. It had one candidate, who polled 1,863 votes.

A Closer Look at US House Results for Minor Parties

If one desires to know if a party improved its performance compared to an election two years previous, U.S. House results are the best office to examine. This is because they are up every two years, nationwide.

Libertarians contested 73 particular U.S. House seats in both 2004 and 2006, and the competitive conditions for each of those 73 seats was the same. That is, in all 73 instances, there were the same number of major party candidates in the race both times (i.e., either both times there was both a Democrat and a Republican in the race, or else both times only one major party ran anyone).

In these 73 elections in which the conditions were roughly the same in both 2004 and 2006, Libertarian percentages increased in 42 districts and decreased in 31 districts.

The Constitution Party contested 12 such U.S. House elections in both 2004 and 2006. Constitution percentages were up in 8 of those districts, and down in 4 districts.

The Green Party contested 11 such districts in both 2004 and 2006. Green percentages were up in 4, and down in 7.

Virginia Republican Party Closed Primary Case Re-Argued in US District Court

On November 16, the U.S. District Court in Richmond, Virginia, again heard Miller v Brown, 3:05cv-266. The issue is whether the First Amendment protects the Republican Party’s right to insist on a closed primary for itself. The case was originally rejected by U.S. District Court Judge Henry Hudson (a Bush Jr. appointee) on procedural issues, but the 4th circuit had said the case is procedurally sound, and should be heard on its merits. The state defended Virginia’s existing system by saying that if the Republican Party doesn’t like having an open primary, it is always free to hold a nominating convention instead. The state also complained that if the party wins the case, the state will be forced to institute registration by party. It was difficult to predict which way Judge Hudson will rule.

Green Party Gubernatorial Total

With approximately 98% of the votes counted, the Green Party gubernatorial candidates polled 854,474 votes across the nation. This is the highest vote total for the gubernatorial candidates of any party (other than the Democratic and Republican Parties) since the Reform Party’s 1998 showing of 1,355,731.

The Libertarian gubernatorial total this year so far is 421,910.

For First Time Since 1998, Libertarians Fall Short of 1,000,000 Votes for US House

Teddy Roosevelt’s Progressive Party polled 2,205,542 votes for its candidates for US House in 1912, and 1,117,939 votes for that office in 1914.

But after that, no party other than the Democratic and Republican Parties had ever polled as much as 1,000,000 votes for its candidates for US House, until the Libertarians did it in 2000, 2002, and 2004. The totals were: 2000 1,727,181; 2002 1,204,248; 2004 1,026,668.

But in 2006, the Libertarians have fallen short of that benchmark. With approximately 98% of the national vote now counted, the Libertarian total (not including the special election in the Texas 22nd district) stands at 608,308. The lower total is a consequence of fewer Libertarian candidates this year (for that office) than in any year since 1994.

The US Senate Libertarian total this year so far is 602,436.

This year, the 2nd highest total for US House was achieved by the Green Party, whose total now stands at 273,071. The Green US Senate total so far is 358,067.