Working Families Party Wins South Carolina Ballot Case

On September 11, a U.S. District Court issued an injunction, directing South Carolina to place the Working Families Party nominees on the November 2006 ballot. The issue was the deadline for turning in the party petition. The law says the petition is due six months before the general election, and the party complied with this law. But the state then argued that the party should not be allowed to nominate any nominees this year, since the schedule for party nomination meetings for older parties requires that those meetings take place in the early spring.

The state had been sued over this issue in 1996, by the Natural Law Party, and in court had conceded that it was wrong. This year, the Election Commission decided to ignore what it had done in 1996 and put up a fight to keep the Working Families Party off this year’s ballot. However, the party won. The case is Working Families Party v South Carolina Election Commission, 3:06cv-2125.

Pennsylvania Supreme Court to Hear Romanelli Appeal

On September 11, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court agreed to hear Romanelli v Caroselli, 132 MM 2006. The issue is whether anyone eligible to register to vote may sign a petition for a minor party or independent candidate, or whether only registered voters may sign. If one reads the Pennsylvania Constitution and the Pennsylvania election code, both seem to say clearly that anyone eligible to register may sign. Ralph Nader raised the same issue in 2004, but the State Supreme Court refused to rule on it since he hadn’t raised that point in the lower court. In the new case, Romanelli did raise it in the lower court, which rejected the claim.

6th Circuit Refuses to Remove Michigan Initiative From the Ballot

On September 11, the 6th circuit refused to disturb last week’s U.S. District Court decision, leaving the anti-affirmative action initiative on the Michigan ballot. The District Court had found that some of the circulators tricked people into signing, but said even without the trickery, the initiative would have had enough valid signatures.

3-Way Colorado Gubernatorial Debate

On September 9, the Democratic, Republican and Libertarian Party candidates for Governor of Colorado debated each other in Grand Junction. Two other candidates for Governor who are on the ballot, the Constitution Party nominee, as well as independent Paul Fiorino, were not permitted to debate.