New York Likely to Have Eleven or Twelve Parties on Statewide Ballot

On September 16, the New York State Board of Elections met and determined whether various petitions for independent candidates, and the nominees of unqualified parties, should be determined valid.  In New York, the Board disqualifies such petitions even if no one challenges, if the petitions on their face lack any possibility of containing enough valid signatures.

The only statewide petition invalidated by the Board was the petition of Sam Sloan, who is a Libertarian but who is not the party’s nominee.  He had nevertheless submitted a petition with his own name and the party label “Libertarian”, but it did not contain 15,000 signatures.

Therefore, these parties will be on the ballot for statewide office:  the five qualified parties (Democratic, Republican, Independence, Conservative, Working Families), followed by these parties:  Anti-Prohibition, Freedom, Green, Libertarian, Rent is 2 Damn High, Tea, and Taxpayers.  Although the Taxpayers Party is on the ballot now, a lawsuit is pending on whether that petition is valid.  The Taxpayers nominee for Governor is Carl Paladino, who is also the Republican nominee.

The Tea Party gubernatorial nominee is Steven Cohn, an attorney from Long Island.  His petition had been challenged by allies of Carl Paladino, but the Tea Party petition survived.  Cohn is supported by Bobby Kumar, who has been active in the Independence Party and who briefly held himself out last year as national chair of the Reform Party.

The Freedom Party gubernatorial nominee is Charles Barron, who is angry with the Democratic Party because all six of the Democratic Party’s statewide nominees this year are non-Hispanic whites.

In 2006, when New York last held a gubernatorial election, nine parties had statewide nominees.  When there are more than eight parties, New York puts two parties in the same party column.  In 2006, the Rent is Too Damn High Party and the Socialist Workers Party were squeezed into the same column.  This year, all six or seven of the unqualified parties will be squeezed into columns that contain two parties.  If there are twelve parties on the ballot, that will be the most crowded general election for statewide office in New York’s history.  However, even if there are twelve parties on, there would only be nine gubernatorial candidates on, because the Independence and Working Families Parties are cross-endorsing the Democratic nominee, and the Taxpayers Party is cross-endorsing the Republican nominee.


Comments

New York Likely to Have Eleven or Twelve Parties on Statewide Ballot — 5 Comments

  1. When will the Donkey/Elephant party hacks in ALL States copy the ballot access laws of certain States — that de facto wipe out third parties and independents ???

  2. I was not aware of a current lawsuit regarding the Taxpayers Party in New York. The line was founded in August with twice the number of signatures needed to get on the ballot. They would have to either invalidate over 15,000 signatures, or prove that an election law was broken in obtaining the signatures.

    There is currently some discussion about the line being invalidated due to the fact that Carl’s Lt. Governor choice, Ognibene did not win in the primaries. Although, Ognibene can take a judgeship, leave the state, or decline the parties nomination which would allow the appointed board for the party to fill the vacancy. I can only assume they would have to fill it with Edwards, which makes it a bit of a sticky mess.

    If you have any links to info about this lawsuit I would love it if you can send it to me. Thanks.

  3. Bobby Kumar was a close associate of Frank MacKay, the boss of the Independence Party. If the Tea Party gets permanent ballot status, will it be a second puppet of MacKay that is just co-opting the popular name, or is it real?

  4. Why would “all six or seven of the unqualified parties will be squeezed into columns that contain two parties.”? New York State no longer uses the old style lever type machines. For the first time this year, starting with the primaries in September, the whole State uses electronic card readers where a box is checked next to the name. Therefore, all of the candidates names will appear in one column on the card with an extra space for a write-in vote. (Not that some of the district election offices bother to tally up the write-in votes.)

  5. The petition filed by Sam Sloan purporting to be the Libertarian candidate was a sham. He took the official petition, substituted his name for that of the legitimate candidate, Warren Redlich, and submitted 288 “signatures” (all in the same handwriting). The minimum statutory requirement is 15,000.

    The Libertarian Party submitted over 33,500 signatures for the Redlich/Link slate of six candidates for state-wide office.

    Mark Axinn
    Chair, LPNY

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.