Ninth Circuit Sets Oral Argument Date in Montana Ballot Access Case

The Ninth Circuit will hear Montana Green Party v Stapleton, 20-35340, on May 6, Wednesday, in Portland, Oregon. This case challenges the unequal distribution requirement for petitions to recognize a new party. The law requires signatures from at least one-third of the state house districts. Montana has 100 state house districts, so signatures must be gathered from at least 34 counties. The problem is that even though the state house districts are approximately equal in population, the law requires widely differing numbers of signatures from the various districts. In some districts as few as 55 signatures are required; in others, 150 signatures. This seems to violate the U.S. Supreme Court decision Moore v Ogilvie, a 1969 case from Illinois that said such laws give more power to the voters of some areas than other areas, and therefore violate the one person, one vote principle.


Comments

Ninth Circuit Sets Oral Argument Date in Montana Ballot Access Case — 4 Comments

  1. That different number of votes are needed to be elected from different districts is surely a violation of the PRINCIPLE of one person, one vote.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.