Albany, New York ABC TV Station WTEN has this article about why New York only has the Democratic and Republican nominees this year on the ballot for all the statewide offices.
Albany, New York ABC TV Station WTEN has this article about why New York only has the Democratic and Republican nominees this year on the ballot for all the statewide offices.
Another problem we would not have at any point if all voters can form parties on the spot in an election by standing or grouping together followed by standing count or hand count.
@Stanley,
How would this work for the election of governor in New York?
Wouldn’t it better to have a record vote?
WHEN DID STANDING/HAND COUNTS END – ESP IN LARGER POP STATES ???
ANY STATES STILL HAVING VERY OLDE SMALL POP TOWNSHIP ELECTIONS IN PERSON ???
@AZ,
Yes.
https://vtdigger.org/2026/03/03/photos-vermont-town-meeting-day-2026/
This is a feature about a man who has moderated the Kirby, Vt. Town meeting for 60 years.
https://www.wcax.com/video/2026/02/25/kirby-man-has-served-town-moderator-60-years-hes-running-again/
John McClaughry has a Political Science degree from UC Berkeley (1963). I wonder if Richard Winger knows him?
He hoboed around the country, and considering moving to Alaska (too cold); Eastern Tennessee (attached to segregationist middle and western Tennessee; and Vermont (Northwest Kingdom). He moved to Kirby in 1967 and built a log cabin, and at 26 was elected moderator at the Town Meeting.
Jim Riley, you ask the same questions each time.
For elections of office too big for a single meeting place vote, so long as that practice persists, an office elected is representative to the next level up meeting for as many levels as needed.
Please explain record vote. I suggest all votes be recorded and broadcast for both concurrent and subsequent viewing from anywhere anytime.
Do you mean something else?
Thank you for the Vermont articles. I’ll take a look.
Congress has time, place, manner authority over the election of Representatives and time, manner authority over the election of US Senators (they don’t have place authority over the election of senators since that would imply dictating the meeting place of the legislatures).
So Congress could require voters in each congressional district to meet and elect their representative. They could dictate the location or leave it up to the States (or communities). They could do the same for senators, letting the States to choose location. Senate and representative elections need not be on the same dates, and could even be on different dates throughout the country.
If no candidate received a majority, there could immediately be a new vote. When Congress set the manner for certain senatorial elections, they would hold a new vote weekly.
Voters would line up, have their name called, and step up to a microphone, state their name and their vote. The secretary would repeat their vote and record it on tally sheets. Your method is apparently dependent on 21st Century technology.
Voters might become disgruntled about the huge crowds, and would agitate for creation of new States (much as Kentucky, Maine, and West Virginia) have. There would be a push to increase the size of House. Organically there would be a recognition of smaller communities that your idea assumes.
JR
HOW MANY SECONDS FOR EACH VOTER TO VOTE IN PUBLIC FOR EACH OFFICE / ISSUE ???
NOOOO MORE ***SECRET*** BALLOTS ???
SORRY — NOW AIN’T 500 BC ANCIENT GREECE AND A FEW HUNDRED VOTERS VOTING ON 1 OR MORE TOP HACKS WITH OLDE BLACK/WHITE STONES
@AZ,
There would be only one office at each meeting.
Let’s say 5 votes per minute. New York had 5,852,707 votes cast in the 2022 senatorial election.
1,170,541 minutes; 19,509 hours; 813 days; just short of 27 months.
Congress required use of voice voting in certain senatorial election.
I don’t call for huge crowds and modern technology isn’t required. It helps with recording, and with travel there and back in sparse population areas, but otherwise this could be done hundreds or thousands of years ago.
No meeting would have over a thousand voters.
So long as elections to offices requiring more voters than that to meet exist, they would elect representatives to next level up conventions and repeat the process as many levels as needed.
Not sure why you want to keep inventing different scenarios I don’t support and call them my system. We’ve been over this many times now.
Spambot nonsense;
Less than one second per vote.
Good riddance to secret votes. They aren’t secret anyway now that many of them are no excuse absentee or vote by snail and just about everyone carries a camera in their phone on them everywhere. Anyone can blackmail or bribe a voter and get proof by ballot harvesting or ballot selfie.
No black or white stones. No hacks. One vote per election.
See thus months recently posted monthly ban issue thread for much more complete explanation.
Those comments are at
https://ballot-access.org/2026/10/27/october-2026-ballot-access-news-print-edition/#comments
Scroll down to
https://ballot-access.org/2026/10/27/october-2026-ballot-access-news-print-edition/#comment-1364720
For start of those
In addition to size of population of New York – 20 plus times the maximum population of a sane nation, 200+ times the ideal – far too many of them are allowed to vote.
Over a quarter of the total population voted, whereas only about 1 in a thousand should realistically be expected to meet all of the voting criteria that should ideally exist.
For US Congress, if dissolving the union does not precede, one good place to start is having it elected by state legislatures.
At the foundation of the USA, there were 2-3 million people living in its thirteen States. There may have been 30,000 people per congressional district. Women, negroes, indentured servants, and men who didn’t own property or couldn’t pay poll taxes or town and state church taxes couldn’t vote. The voting age was 21, which was about half the average lifespan – functionally, around 40 years old today.
Each congressman had a four figure number of voting constituents then. And most people thought of themselves primarily as state rather than federal citizens, so state legislatures were more important than congress. The average state legislator had a three figure number of voting constituents – that is less than a thousand.
I’ve proposed a thousand voters as the upper limit of a sane nation state.
Continued at link above over several comments st
Re: VT articles
In person town meetings with votes still take place all over New England.
I addressed the expansion of congress in the referenced comments as did Helpful Guy and others.
I think many voters in New York will be writing in Larry Sharpe for Governor.
I don’t.
@Stanley,
You can not have a record vote in one second per voter. The Secretary can not write that fast. Have you ever participated in a standing count, a sitting count, or a hand count? They are not record votes.
My variant of your proposal is feasible under the current Constitution and likely would lead to the creation of many new States and expansion of Congress organically, rather than automagically under your concept.
Yes, I have.
Video recording.
If you want written records, they can be done at someone’s leisure later from the video.
My concept does not call for any expansion of congress. See linked discussion.
For context see also comments by AIden, Dennis, Helpful Guy and Q in that discussion in addition to my own, if the subject of congressional size and my thoughts on it interest you at all.
That may, however, be asking far too much, given apparent failure to either read or take into account what I’ve plainly said directly above and in back and forth in any number of previous discussions here with Jim Riley.
But it’s here and at the provided link if Mr. Riley or any interested readers, should they happen to exist, are interested.
Please explain the point of or obsession with written records.
By the end of this century there will probably be an equal portion of the population familiar with Roman or other alphabetical squiggles as are currently conversant with Egyptian hieroglyphics.
Supposing a vote is broadcast and recorded and public either way, concurrent as well as on demand by anyone anywhere any time thereafter as I propose, anyone can double check the count at any time.
It can be translated into any written alphabet, system of pictographs, or any other translation system anyone knows and wants to use when and wherever demand exists.
Whitfield said:
“I think many voters in New York will be writing in Larry Sharpe for Governor.”
Then you are a fucking retard.
For this to be an effective protest they would need to spend more money than a viable signature drive would take.
What would count as “many”?
Imprecise, unfalsifiable prediction by GW unless some number or percentage gets attached.
@Stanley,
How would your scheme have been implemented in 1980, 1880, 1780?
In 1980 video recording was fairly widespread. I recall doing some myself.
In 1880, audio recording was available but not as yet, if I recall reading correctly, very widespread or affordable. They would have probably generally used written records.
In 1780, written records were state of the art technology. Writing was generally by quill and printing was an arduous process requiring expertise that took apprenticeship to learn and significant resources to operate.
Luckily we no longer live in the last millennia, so why does that matter?
How it will be implemented in 2080 is a lot more interesting to me, although it’s extremely unlikely I’ll be alive. If I do, I’ll be older than anyone is proven to have lived since early Old Testament times.