The Boston Globe has this lengthy analysis of how top-two has affected elections in California and Washington.
Comments
Boston Globe Story on How Top-Two Has Affected California and Washington — 4 Comments
NOOO RIGGED EXTREMIST PRIMARIES
—
ONE ELECTION DAY PER CYCLE
EQUAL BALLOT ACCESS
PR – LEGIS
APPV – NONPARTISAN EXECS/JUDICS
TOTSOP
“Simplicity and clarity can be really valuable in our elections, and this incentivizes a lot of conniving and strategizing … that takes away from a more straightforward, understandable process,”
Precisely the problem with all current elections.
I don’t believe increasing turnout should be a goal – way too many people vote as it is, and I would be disqualified myself under my proposals for a variety of reasons, such as being too old, divorced, and no longer in fighting shape.
But if it was a goal, did it actually increase turnout?
Nominally nonpartisan elections, proportional representation, and approval voting are bad ideas.
Total separation of powers is a theoretically good idea that doesn’t work at achieving its goal and only makes government more complicated, which, as with elections, is a bad thing.
One election day per cycle is a good idea. Like a broken clock, the AZ spambot is very occasionally accidentally correct.
Equal voter access is automatic under my proposals.
Independent candidates only succeed where there is a small isolated electorate where the candidates can reach voters om a personal level. By definition, independents don’t have a permanent, persistent, political organization. If they did, it would become a political party. When Angus King or Bernie Sanders retire or die (they are 85 and 82, respectively), their successor may campaign as maintaining their legacy, but they will be Democrats.
California legislative districts are enormous and most are in gigantic metropolitan areas, where candidates must depend on mass media to attempt to reach voters.
Washington legislative districts are also large. Because senate and house districts are the same, they tend to align politically over time. In the past, there was a slight tendency to split the house seats between the two parties. A “bipartisan” voter might vote for one Democrat and one Republican. Incumbency gave a slight advantage. Parties would ordinarily run their stronger challenger against the less-experienced candidate.
Imagine the incumbent senator has retired, or run for Congress or state office. The more experienced representative (say for Position 1) runs for Senate. Voters are not going to decide that they liked Joe or Marie as a representative, but he doesn’t have “senatorial” qualities. The voters are the same. They might not even recognize that Mr. Smith is running for a different office. Maybe Mr. Smith gave a speech at their garden club a few years ago. The representative for Position 2 is running for re-election. The “in” party would have to run a newcomer for Position 1, which would make them more vulnerable to a challenge. This sometimes led to House members from different parties. But this would not be stable.
The nail that sticks out will be hammered down.
Contrast with Alaska which has small house districts. They are about 1/9 the size of Washington districts, and many are geographically isolated. As many as 7 independent candidates may be elected to the Alaska House this year.
Excessive number of voters in an election is a big problem. It shouldn’t be above a thousand, with a hundred being ideal.
NOOO RIGGED EXTREMIST PRIMARIES
—
ONE ELECTION DAY PER CYCLE
EQUAL BALLOT ACCESS
PR – LEGIS
APPV – NONPARTISAN EXECS/JUDICS
TOTSOP
“Simplicity and clarity can be really valuable in our elections, and this incentivizes a lot of conniving and strategizing … that takes away from a more straightforward, understandable process,”
Precisely the problem with all current elections.
I don’t believe increasing turnout should be a goal – way too many people vote as it is, and I would be disqualified myself under my proposals for a variety of reasons, such as being too old, divorced, and no longer in fighting shape.
But if it was a goal, did it actually increase turnout?
Nominally nonpartisan elections, proportional representation, and approval voting are bad ideas.
Total separation of powers is a theoretically good idea that doesn’t work at achieving its goal and only makes government more complicated, which, as with elections, is a bad thing.
One election day per cycle is a good idea. Like a broken clock, the AZ spambot is very occasionally accidentally correct.
Equal voter access is automatic under my proposals.
Independent candidates only succeed where there is a small isolated electorate where the candidates can reach voters om a personal level. By definition, independents don’t have a permanent, persistent, political organization. If they did, it would become a political party. When Angus King or Bernie Sanders retire or die (they are 85 and 82, respectively), their successor may campaign as maintaining their legacy, but they will be Democrats.
California legislative districts are enormous and most are in gigantic metropolitan areas, where candidates must depend on mass media to attempt to reach voters.
Washington legislative districts are also large. Because senate and house districts are the same, they tend to align politically over time. In the past, there was a slight tendency to split the house seats between the two parties. A “bipartisan” voter might vote for one Democrat and one Republican. Incumbency gave a slight advantage. Parties would ordinarily run their stronger challenger against the less-experienced candidate.
Imagine the incumbent senator has retired, or run for Congress or state office. The more experienced representative (say for Position 1) runs for Senate. Voters are not going to decide that they liked Joe or Marie as a representative, but he doesn’t have “senatorial” qualities. The voters are the same. They might not even recognize that Mr. Smith is running for a different office. Maybe Mr. Smith gave a speech at their garden club a few years ago. The representative for Position 2 is running for re-election. The “in” party would have to run a newcomer for Position 1, which would make them more vulnerable to a challenge. This sometimes led to House members from different parties. But this would not be stable.
The nail that sticks out will be hammered down.
Contrast with Alaska which has small house districts. They are about 1/9 the size of Washington districts, and many are geographically isolated. As many as 7 independent candidates may be elected to the Alaska House this year.
Excessive number of voters in an election is a big problem. It shouldn’t be above a thousand, with a hundred being ideal.