Los Angeles Times Associate Editor Writes on California’s Top-Two System

Nicholas Goldberg, an associate editor of the Los Angeles Times, has this analysis of California’s top-two system. The piece quotes three political scientists. Two of them believe it has been beneficial, and one of them does not. Ironically, all three of these political scientists expressed these opinions twelve years ago when the system was passed by the voters.

The article is balanced, but fails to mention the biggest impact that the California and Washington top-two systems has produced: a complete elimination of minor party candidates on the general election ballot, except in races in which one of the major parties doesn’t run anyone. Thanks to Eric Wong for the link. The piece has been published in many newspapers besides just the Los Angeles Times.

Kansas Supreme Court Says U.S. House District Boundaries Don’t Violate State Constitution

On May 18, the Kansas Supreme Court issued a two-page opinion, reversing the lower state court and upholding the U.S. House districts passed by the legislature earlier this year. The lower court had said the maps represent a partisan gerrymander which is prohibited by the Kansas Constitution. The State Supreme Court did not explain its reasoning, but says it will do that later. It is unclear if the decision was unanimous. Rivera v Schwab, case number 125092.

Alaska Bill, Easing Definition of a Qualified Party, Passes Legislature

On May 17, the Alaska House passed SB 161 by a vote of 37-2. It eases the definition of a qualified political party, from a group with registration equal to 3% of the last vote cast (approximately 11,000 members) to exactly 5,000 registered members. Assuming the Governor signs the bill, the immediate effect will be to restore the Libertarian Party’s qualified status. Obviously it will also make it easier for the Green Party to regain its status. The Green Party now has 1,490 registrants, but back in October 2002 it had 4,789.

The two representatives who voted “no” are George Rauscher and Sarah Vance, both Republicans.

Montana Supreme Court Rules Against Electronic Ballot Access Signatures

On May 17, the Montana Supreme Court issued an opinion in Meyer v Jacobsen, 2022 Mt 93. The decision holds that the law does not permit an independent candidate to submit electronic signatures. The case had been brought by John Meyer, an independent candidate who tried and failed to get on the ballot in 2020 as an independent candidate for Attorney General.

Alaska Democrats Fear that No Democrat Will be in the Top Four, in Special U.S. House Election

This article says that Alaska Democrats worry that in the June11 primary for U.S. House, no Democrat will place in the first four slots. The law, passed by the voters in November 2020 and being used for the first time next month, says the top four primary candidates are the only ones that can get on the general election ballot. Polls are suggesting that Republican Nick Begich and Sarah Palin, and independent Al Gross, will be in the top four. The fourth-place finisher is tough to predict, but independent candidate Santa Claus has a miniscule lead.