U.S. District Court in West Virginia Rejects Kanye West’s Ballot Access Lawsuit

On September 14, U.S. District Court Judge Irene C. Berger, an Obama appointee, issued an opinion in West v Warner, s.d., 2:20cv-570. West had submitted approximately 14,000 signatures to be an independent presidential candidate in West Virginia, but election officials found he didn’t have as many as 7,145 valid; instead only about 6,400 were valid.

West sued to say that the state must give him a chance to re-validate signatures. But the Judge said if he was concerned that the checking process wouldn’t be accurate or fair, he should have submitted his petitions on a piece-meal basis. Instead he turned all of them in on the August 3 petition deadline. It is true that West Virginia will permit petitions to be submitted in stages. The judge also said he didn’t submit any evidence of any particular signature that had been unfairly rejected. Here is the 10-page opinion.

Black Caucus Florida Legislators Oppose Top-Two Initiative

This story says that members of Florida’s legislative Black Caucus have come out in opposition to the top-two initiative in Florida.

The story also quotes John Opdycke, President of Open Primaries (a group that supports top-two systems) as saying that California had closed primaries for state office before California switched to the top-two system. This is not true. California had semi-closed primaries for congress and state office between 2002 and 2010. John Opdycke knows this because he and I have had face-to-face conversations about this. The proof that California had semi-closed primaries, both Republican and Democratic, for congress and state office can be seen from the California Secretary of State’s website.

The Only Alternative Congressional Candidates in South Carolina are Constitution Party Nominees

South Carolina has a U.S. Senate election this year, and has seven U.S. House districts. The only candidates on the ballot this year for either house of Congress, other than Republicans and Democrats. are Constitution Party nominees. The Constitution Party is running for U.S. Senate, and has three nominees for U.S. House.

New York Working Families Party Nominates Joe Biden

On August 11, the New York Working Families Party nominated Joe Biden for president. This means he will be on the New York ballot twice, and voters can vote for him either as a Democrat or as a Working Families Party candidate.

In 2016, when the WFP nominated Hillary Clinton in New York, the party polled 139,840 votes for her, which was 1.83%.

The April 2020 new law on party status requires the greater of 130,000 votes, or 2%. So unless the new law is eventually declared unconstitutional, it is tough to predict whether the WFP can meet the new standard later this year.

New York Conservative Party Nominates President Trump

On August 29, the New York Conservative Party chose President Donald J. Trump as its presidential nominee. This means he will be listed twice on the New York, and voters who want to vote for him can do so under the Republican label or the Conservative label. The convention was virtual.

In 2016, Trump was also the Conservative Party nominee. As a Conservative nominee got 291,947 votes, 3.81%.