Women’s Equality Party in New York Seems Unlikely to Survive After 2018

New York defines a qualified party as a group that got at least 50,000 votes for Governor. The 2016 showing for the Women’s Equality Party suggests that the party will not poll that many votes for Governor in 2018. For the two statewide races in 2016, the Women’s Equality Party only polled 35,706 votes for President, and 44,817 for U.S. Senator. Voter turnout in New York, as in all states, is significantly higher in presidential years than in midterm years. Because the Women’s Equality Party couldn’t even poll 50,000 votes in 2016, when voter turnout is high, it isn’t likely to poll that many votes in 2018, when turnout will be lower. Here is a link to the New York 2016 election returns, which were released on December 8.

Nevada State Senator Asks Legislative Staff to Draft a Bill for a Top-Two System

Nevada State Senator James Settelmeyer (R-Minden) has asked legislative staff to draft a bill to put a top-two system in place in Nevada. The draft probably won’t be available until February. Senator Settelmeyer reportedly isn’t fully persuaded of the virtue of a top-two system but apparently wants the idea aired. Thanks to Doug Goodman for this news.

West Virginia Minor Parties Did Very Well in 2016 in Down-Ticket Races

Last month, West Virginia minor parties did unusually well in races below president. For Governor, Mountain Party nominee Charlotte Pritt polled 5.89% of the vote, the best showing for a West Virginia gubernatorial nominee who was not the Democratic or Republican nominee since 1992, when she (as a Democratic write-in candidate in November) polled 7.38%. If one excludes the Pritt 1992 showing, no minor party or independent had polled as much as 5% for West Virginia Governor since 1920.

The only November 2016 Libertarian nominee for U.S. House, Zane Lawhorn in the 3rd district, polled 8.14%. This was the highest percentage for anyone running for U.S. House in West Virginia who was not a Democratic or Republican nominee, and who was running in a district with both major parties in the race, since Ken Hechler was a write-in in 1976. Hechler was the Democratic incumbent at the time. Setting aside his example, the Libertarian 2016 showing for U.S. House (in races with both major parties also running) was the best for any minor party or independent since 1914.

Also, the Libertarian nominee for Agriculture Commissioner, Buddy Guthrie, polled 10.31%. The Republican got 48.41% and the Democrat got 41.28%. This was the best showing for a non-major party nominee for statewide office since Ross Perot’s 1996 showing.

The Socialist Equality Party nominee for State House, 16th district, Naomi Spencer Daly, received the vote of 6.87% of the voters who cast a ballot in her race. She was the only legislative nominee of any party with “Socialist” or “Socialism” in its name on the ballot anywhere in the United States this year.

West Virginia did not have a U.S. Senate election in 2016.

Ken Hechler Dies

On December 10, 2016, Ken Hechler died at the age of 102. A Democrat, he was elected to the U.S. House from West Virginia in 1958, and re-elected in all subsequent elections through 1974. In 1976 he sought the Democratic nomination for Governor. He did not win that primary, so then he launched a write-in campaign to keep his seat in the U.S. House. Although he did not win a write-in, he placed second, ahead of the Republican. The November 1976 vote for District Four was Democrat Nick Rahall 45.6%; Hechler 36.6%; and Republican E.S. Goodman 17.8%.

In 1984 he was elected Secretary of State of West Virginia, and he was re-elected in 1988, 1992, and 1996. In 1995 he ruled that unqualified parties would be permitted to use stand-in presidential candidates on their petitions, a ruling sought by the Libertarian Party that is still in effect today.