Dueling Colorado Proposals on How Parties Nominate Candidates

Colorado now has closed primary elections, and generally only the Democratic and Republican Parties have primary elections, although in rare cases qualified minor parties also have them. Also, currently, Colorado has no presidential primaries

An initiative is circulating that would amend the law so that independent voters could vote in a special primary ballot that includes the names of all candidates. The initiative says if a party doesn’t like that, if three-fourths of the members of the state central committee choose to nominate for all office by party meeting instead of a primary, that is allowed. However, the proponents know that it is very difficult for any party to pass anything that controversial with a three-fourths vote. Here is the text of the initiative.

Another initiative is circulating that would provide for a presidential primary. Here is the text. It says that independents could vote in any party’s presidential primary.

Finally, a bill in the legislature would set up a presidential primary. It provides that all independent voters would be free to temporarily join a party, and then they could vote in that party’s presidential primary, and they would automatically become independents again a few months after the presidential primary. The bill, HB 1454, passed the House Committee that handles election law bills on April 25, and it passed the House Appropriations Committee on April 28. However, it was amended on April 28 to say that if any initiative on the subject of presidential primaries passes in November, that initiative is automatically amended to say that any party is free to choose to nominate for all office by party meeting instead of by primary.

Proponents of HB 1454 inserted this amendment to help defeat the presidential primary initiative if it gets on the ballot. Proponents of the bill say that the presidential primary initiative idea would cost far too much money. This is because all registered voters in Colorado automatically receive ballots in the postal mail, and proponents of HB 1454 say that if the initiative passes, thousands of ballots would need to be mailed to all independents (the envelope would include both a Democratic ballot and a Republican ballot), and many or most of those ballots would never be returned and would be wasted. By contrast, the bill requires independents to request a presidential primary ballot, so fewer ballots would need to be printed and mailed.

Libertarian Party is Only Oklahoma Party to have a Statewide Primary on June 28

Oklahoma holds a primary (for all partisan office except President) on June 28. Oklahoma does not permit write-ins, and when only one candidate files in any particular race, Oklahoma removes that office from the ballot, whether it is a primary ballot or a general election ballot.

Only two statewide offices are up in Oklahoma this year, U.S. Senate and Corporation Commissioner. Because there is only one Democrat and one Republican running for each of those two offices, those offices are off the major party primary ballots. Republican and Democratic primary ballots will therefore only be printed in areas with a contest between at least two candidates for district or county partisan office. As a result, there is no Democratic primary, and no Republican primary, in most of the precincnts in the state.

But because there are two Libertarians running for U.S. Senate, there will be statewide Libertarian primary. The Libertarian Party allows independents to vote in its primaries. The two U.S. Senate Libertarian candidates are Robert Murphy and Dax Ewbank. Thanks to E. Zachary Knight for this news.

Only Twenty of the Thirty-Four California Candidates for U.S. Senate Appear in State Voter Information Guide

Before every statewide election for candidates, California officials postally mail an “Official Voter Information Guide” to all registered voters. In years when U.S. Senate is up, the Guide contains candidate statements and pictures for all Senate candidates who pay to be in the guide. This year there are 34 candidates on the June 7, 2016 primary ballot, for U.S. Senate. Only 20 paid to be in the book.

Twelve Republicans are on the ballot, but only seven of them are in the book: Greg Conlon, Von Hougo, Don Krampe, Jerry Laws, Tom Palzer, Karen Roseberry, and Duf Sundheim. The state charges $25 per word. A candidate’s web address is considered to be one word. If a candidate pays $25 to have a web address listed, then the state includes a picture, a postal address, and a phone number for free. So, for only $25, a candidate will be in the book but with no text except contact information and picture.

At the Republican state party convention in Burlingame on May 2, only eight Republican candidates for U.S. Senate addressed the body. Sundheim, one of those eight, criticized his opponents Tom Del Beccaro and Ron Unz for not having paid to be listed in the state book. The other Republicans who addressed the convention are Greg Conlon, Tom Del Beccaro, Von Hougo, Tom Palzer, Karen Roseberry, Ron Unz, and Phil Wyman. Unz was unable to appear in the book because by the time he decided to run, on the last day to file for the ballot, it was already too late to file to be in the book.

Seven Democrats are on the ballot. Those who are in the book are President Cristina Grappo, Kamala Harris, Massie Munroe, Herb Peters, and Loretta Sanchez.

Two Libertarians are on the ballot, but neither filed to be in the book. The only Green who is on the ballot, Pam Elizondo, is in the book and by random luck, is listed first in the book. The only Peace & Freedom Party member who is on the ballot is not in the book.

Eleven candidates are on the ballot with the label “Party preference: none”. Seven of them are in the book: Mike Beitiks, Tim Gildersleeve, Don Grundmann, Jason Hanania, Jason Kraus, Paul Merritt, and Ling Ling Shi. Grundmann is registered in the Constitution Party but he was not allowed to say that in the book. Paul Merritt said in his statement that he is a registered independent voter, but the Secretary of State censored that out of Merritt’s statement. Merritt is suing over that.

One candidate is in the book but is not on the ballot. He is Akinyemi Olabode Agbede, a Democrat. He is not on the ballot because his candidate filing fee bounced, but by the time that was known, the booklet had already been printed.

Montana Republicans Waive Trial in Open Primary Case

Ever since 2014, some Montana Republican County Central Committees have been trying to win a federal lawsuit against the open primary as applied to the Republican Party. The case is Ravalli County Republican Central Committee v McCulloch, cv14-58. On May 2, the county parties filed paperwork with the U.S. District Court voluntarily dropping the case within the U.S. District Court. That means the trial, to present evidence on whether the open primary harms the party, will not be held.

However, the county Republican Parties are still pressing ahead with their appeal of an earlier decision by the U.S. District Court not to enjoin the 2016 open primary. That appeal will be argued in the Ninth Circuit on May 4, in Portland, Oregon.

The state Republican Party had joined this case after it had been filed, but recently dropped out of the case. The three judges who will be hearing the Ninth Circult appeal are Judges A. Wallace Tashima, Richard Tallman (both are Clinton appointees), and AndrewHurwitz (an Obama appointee). Thanks to Mike Fellows for this news.