Analysis of California Blanket Primary Data from 1998-2000 Shows Top-Two Likely to Injure Democrats, Relative to Republicans

Hotline studied California election returns in 1998 and 2000, and determined that the California top-two open primary is likely to injure Democrats, relative to Republicans. See a description here.

In 1998 and 2000, California used a blanket primary. All candidates for all partisan office appeared on the same primary ballot, and all voters used that primary ballot. The top vote-getter from the ranks of each party advanced to the November election. Therefore, the blanket primary did not injure either major party relative to the other. But the data from that period shows that in the top-two open primary now in effect, Republicans gain a significant advantage over Democrats, because Republican voter turnout is consistently higher in primaries than Democratic primary turnout. That means, sometimes, no Democrat ends up on the November ballot, even in races in which Democrats might have been able to win in November, if only they had a candidate on the ballot. Thanks to Rob Richie for the link.

Big Arizona Newspapers Carry Three Pro-Top-Two Items, but so far None on the Other Side

The Arizona Republic (Phoenix), and the Arizona Daily Star (Tucson), the state’s largest two newspapers, have together run three opinion pieces in favor of the top-two open primary initiative, but so far none on the other side.

The Star ran an op-ed in favor of the idea on November 24, 2011. It is by Paul Johnson, former Mayor of Phoenix, and Si Schorr. The title is “Open Elections would Improve Representation, Reduce Hyperpartisanship.”

The Arizona Republic ran a piece on December 4, 2011. It is by Linda Valdez, and is titled “Arizona 2012: Making Government Work.”

The Republic ran a second boost on June 13, 2012. It is by columnist Laurie Roberts. The title is “An open primary is best hope.”

Both newspapers have been asked to carry an opinion piece on the other side, but so far they have not done so. The only media in Arizona so far that has attacked the top-two initiative is the BlogforArizona, which generally seems to support Democrats and oppose Republicans. That blog has an anonymous blogger named “Arizona Blue Meanie”, who has run five blog posts making the case against the top-two idea. Thanks to Thane Eichenauer for the link to BlogforArizona.

California Bill to Make it More Difficult for Constitutional Amendment Initiatives to Qualify for Ballot

On June 19, the California Assembly Elections Committee will hear ACA 10, by Assemblymember Mike Gatto (D-Los Angeles). Currently, an initiative to change the California Constitution needs a petition signed by 8% of the last gubernatorial vote. The proposal would provide that the initiative would also need the signatures of 8% of the last gubernatorial vote in each of at least 27 State Senate districts.

If the legislature passes this proposal, then it would be subject to a popular vote, because it amends the Constitution.