U.S. District Court Judge Raymond J. Dearie, a Reagan appointee, will hold another hearing in Credico v New York State Board of Elections on Tuesday, October 26, at 3 p.m. This is the case over whether Randy Credico should be listed twice on the New York state ballot as a candidate for U.S. Senate. Judge Dearie issued a 10-page memorandum on October 25 and found that New York state lacks any rational reason whatsover to treat Credico differently than someone who is the nominee of two qualified parties. But he stayed his own order until the October 26 hearing.
The memo says that printing Credico’s name on the ballot only once is not a severe burden. But it also says that the claimed state interest in not listing him in both columns (or rows, depending on whether one is talking of the New York city ballot or the ballot in the remainder of the state) is non-existent. The memo says the two parties each have their own line on the ballot anyway, so to refuse to list Credico in both lines is “absurd” and will cause voter confusion.
The purpose of the October 26 hearing is to see if it is true that it is impossible to give relief this election year, due to the fact that the election is only one week away.