Hearing October 9 on Whether Democratic Party Nominees for New York Supreme Court Should Remain on Ballot

A New York state court will hear arguments on October 9, in a case to determine whether the New York Democratic Party’s nominees for Justice of the Supreme Court, 5th district, should remain on the November 3, 2009 ballot. See this story. In New York, Justices of the Supreme Court are elected on a partisan basis, from judicial districts. Nominees are chosen by convention. The 5th district is the area in and around Syracuse. The objector who filed the lawsuit to remove the nominees says the convention procedures did not follow state election laws.

U.S. District Court Issues Injunction Against Law that Says Voters May Only Sign One Nominationg Petition per Office

On October 8, U.S. District Court Judge William E. Smith, a Bush, Jr. appointee, issued an injunction against a law that says voters may only sign one nominating petition for each office. The effect of the ruling is to place Hipolito Fontes on the non-partisan ballot for Mayor of Central Falls, Rhode Island. The election is November 3, 2009.

Central Falls says candidates for Mayor need 200 signatures, and voters may only sign for one candidate. When a voter signs two petitions for the same office, that signature counts for the candidate who submitted the petition first. The case is Fontes v City of Central Falls, 09-437. Here is the order.

The opinion says the law “is not necessary to further the government’s state interests in reducing ballot clutter or in demonstrating a candidate’s support in the community…Defendants have failed to offer any evidence demonstrating how the first to file rule eliminates chaos and clutter in elections.”

Final Briefs Filed in U.S. District Court in Idaho Ballot Access Case

All the briefs have now been filed in Daien v Ysursa, in U.S. District Court in Idaho. The case challenges Idaho’s ban on out-of-state petition circulators. It also challenges Idaho’s law that requires an independent presidential candidate to collect six times as many signatures as are needed for a statewide independent candidate for office other than president. Here is Daien’s brief; here is the State’s brief. Both were filed on October 2.

The plaintiff, Donald Daien, lives in Arizona and he wants to be able to petition for an independent or minor party presidential candidate in 2012 who shares his political views. In the past, Daien has been a volunteer petitioner in many states for Ralph Nader.