Pennsylvania GOP to Appeal Barr Substitution Decision

Republican Party officials in Pennsylvania have notified national Libertarian Party officials that they plan to appeal the Barr substitution decision to the state supreme court.

On September 15, the Pennsylvania Commonwealth ruled against the challenge to Bob Barr’s substitution paperwork. The court decision said “In nominating Etzel prior to the Libertarian National Convention and substituting Barr thereafter, the Party and LPPa merely complied with the Party’s election process as it has been established in Pennsylvania since 1996 when, nationally, the Party moved its convention from a date prior to the legal date for circulation of Pennsylvania nomination papers to a subsequent date. Since then, given the time constraints, the Party and LPPa have deemed it necessary to circulate nomination papers prior to their national convention in order to take full and fair advantage of the time period allotted under Pennsylvania’s Election Code to secure the necessary signatures in support of their candidate…the Party simply took reasonable action to abide by the Election Code while furthering its legitimate interest.”

Barr loses first round in fight to keep Obama and McCain off the Texas ballot

The Atlanta Journal-Constititution reports:

Libertarian presidential candidate Bob Barr has lost the first clash in his strange Texas fight to keep John McCain and Barack Obama off the ballot in that state.

Campaign manager Russ Verney put out word this afternoon that the Barr campaign’s request for an emergency stay, to block the mailing of ballots to overseas military personnel, has been rejected.

The Texas attorney general successfully argued that an order to halt the shipping of ballots would violate the voting rights of those in the armed services.

Barr contends that the Democratic and Republican nominees are disqualified from appearing on the Texas ballot because they missed the state’s Aug. 26 deadline to certify candidates. Obama was not formally named the Democratic candidate until an Aug. 27 vote in Denver. McCain claimed the Republican nomination on Sept. 3 in St. Paul.

Barr, who was kept off the West Virginia ballot because of a missed deadline, says turnabout is fair play.

The news media has been tentative with this story, uncertain whether the Barr lawsuit is a legal move with profound implications — Texas has 34 electoral votes — or another wispy courtroom sideshow.

But the Dallas Morning News on Thursday had these paragraphs:

The Supreme Court has refused to dismiss the case outright and has asked all parties to file their response to the lawsuit by Monday.

Part of the legal basis for the suit is Bush vs. Gore, by which the U.S. Supreme Court held that “the clearly expressed intent of the legislature must prevail,” and that election laws must be uniformly applied and interpreted.

“Sound familiar Mr. Bush? Sound familiar Republicans?” Mr. Barr said, adding that the state law is unambiguous.

“The Libertarian Party like other parties and independent candidates always face a struggle to get on the ballot and are sometimes excluded from the ballot for the most minor of details,” said state party chairman Patrick Dixon. “We may not like the rules, but we have to play by them.”

Meanwhile, Republicans in Pennsylvania have decided to appeal a judge’s decision last week that permitted Barr to remain on the ballot in that state.

Mississippi Supreme Court Says U.S. Senate Race Should be Near Top of Ballot

On September 18, the Mississippi Supreme Court said that the Class I U.S. Senate seat should be near the top of the ballot, near the presidential race and the Class II U.S. Senate seat. However, it declined to order state officials to implement this opinion. However, later on the day, Governor Haley Barbour and the Secretary of State said they would change the ballot to conform to the Mississippi Supreme Court’s Opinion. Thanks to Rick Hasen’s ElectionLawBlog for this news.

The lawsuit was called Barbour v Berger. It had been filed initially because the Governor and the Secretary of State had proposed to put the Class I U.S. Senate seat near the bottom of the ballot, after local races and local ballot questions. The Class I U.S. Senate seat is hotly contested. Critics of the original decision said the motivation was to minimize the number of votes cast in that race, because some voters don’t bother voting on the entire ballot.

Connecticut Libertarians Make Good Progress on Re-Verification of Signatures

Libertarian activists are finding many valid signatures in Connecticut that had been invalidated by town clerks. As noted earlier, the town clerks had initially found that the petition only had a 54% validity rate, and that the party’s presidential petition is 501 signatures short. At the rate activists are finding valid signatures that seem to have been invalidated in error, the evidence that the petition really does have enough valid signatures should be in hand by September 22.

Texas Supreme Court Asks for Democratic, Republican Response in Presidential Deadline Lawsuit

On September 18, the Texas Supreme Court asked the Texas Secretary of State, and the Texas Democratic and Republican Parties, to respond to Bob Barr’s lawsuit over the fact that the two major parties did not certify their national tickets on time. The response is due September 22 at 3 p.m. Thanks to Angela Grover for this news.