Court Date Set for 10th Circuit Argument on Out-of-State Circulators

The 10th Circuit will hear Yes on Term Limits v Savage on September 25, Thursday, in Denver. This is the case on whether the U.S. Constitution protects the ability of out-of-staters to circulate petitions. The case is from Oklahoma. The U.S. District Court had upheld the Oklahoma restriction.

The only 10th circuit precedent in this area of the law is favorable. It is Chandler v City of Arvada, 292 F 3d 1236 (2002). It held that a city could not ban circulators from circulating a city initiative, just because those circulators don’t live in that city. The 10th circuit includes Colorado, Kansas, New Mexico, Oklahoma, Utah and Wyoming. That case arose from Colorado.

Five U.S. Senate Candidates in Louisiana

Friday, July 11, is the Louisiana deadline for filing for Congress, both for candidates running in party primaries, and for independent candidates. The U.S. Senate race will have five candidates on the November ballot: Democratic incumbent Mary Landrieu, a Republican (whoever wins the September primary, John Kennedy or Jacques Boudreax), Libertarian Richard Fontanesi, independent Robert Stewart, and independent Jay Patel.

Fontanesi will be the first U.S. Senate candidate (other than Democrats and Republicans) with a party label next to his name on the November ballot, since 1972, when the American Party was a qualified party and ran Hall Lyons. The Louisiana definition of “political party” was substantially eased in 2004, but it didn’t take effect until 2005. There was no U.S. Senate election in Louisiana in 2006. Fontanesi was a Libertarian candidate for U.S. House in 2006, and polled 17.2% in a race with only one major party contender.

Another Lawsuit Over McCain Eligibility

On April 3, a lawsuit was filed in U.S. District Court in New Hampshire, alleging that John McCain is not eligible under Article II to be president. See the complaint here. Thank to Dan Tokaji for this news. The case is Hollander v McCain, 1:08-cv-99-JL. It has a hearing on July 24. Here is the Republican National Committee’s brief urging that the case be dismissed.

Guam Legislature Moves General Election Presidential Vote to the September Primary

On July 10, the Guam legislature passed Bill 287, which moves the territory’s general election presidential vote from November, to the Guam primary. This year, the Guam primary is on Saturday, September 6. The Governor has until July 24 to sign or veto the bill. If it becomes law, it takes effect this year.

Guam has been voting for president in the general election starting in 1980. Because Guam has no electoral votes, the vote is merely a “straw vote”. Guam has been holding a general election for president in order to draw attention to the fact that the residents of Guam are U.S. citizens, and they must obey the laws passed in Washington, yet they have neither a voting member of Congress, nor any meaningful presidential vote.

The preamble to Bill Number 287 says that the U.S. media never report the Guam presidential vote, which is true. The bill’s preamble says, “It is therefore the intent of I Liheslatura to move the ‘straw poll’ for President and Vice-President from the general election to the primary election so that Guam’s choice for our nation’s highest leaders will be known in advance of the national general election, and draw attention to the continued disenfranchisement of the American citizens living in the American territory of Guam.”

Guam is the only colonial possession of the U.S. to have ever held a general election vote for president. The Puerto Rico legislature passed a similar measure some years ago, but the Puerto Rican Supreme Court ruled that the measure violates the Puerto Rico Constitution.

Presidential candidates get on the Guam general election presidential ballot by showing that they are on the ballot in at least one state, and by writing a letter to the Guam Election Commission. In 2004 the only candidates on the Guam ballot were Bush, Kerry, Nader and Badnarik.