North Carolina Ballot Access Trial Winds Up

The North Carolina ballot access trial is now over. It was conducted on May 5-6, with closing arguments on May 7. During the course of the trial, the plaintiffs (Libertarian and Green Parties) presented 8 witnesses. The state did not present any witnesses who testified in court, although the state did present affidavits from election officials. The state rests its defense of the existing ballot access laws almost solely on the point that (1) the laws had already been upheld in federal court in 1994; (2) North Carolina elects ten statewide state offices in presidential election years, and if there are several minor parties on the ballot, and they run candidates for all these statewide state offices, that will create a ballot that is cumbersome. Some North Carolina counties use optical-scan ballots, and if there are too many offices and too many candidates in the general election, that will take more than a single ballot card for each voter. Other North Carolina counties use touch-screen machines.

An opinion will probably come within the next three weeks. Witnesses for the plaintiffs were two political scientists, Michael Munger and Steven Greene; two Libertarian Party leaders, Barbara Howe and Sean Haugh; three Green Party leaders, Elena Everett, Hart Matthews, and W. Gray Newman; and Richard Winger.

Indiana and North Carolina Primary Results

Live Indiana primary returns.

Although the media is only concentrating on the Democratic primary, the Republican primary is also interesting. With 88% of the vote counted, the Indiana Republican percentages are: McCain 78%, Huckabee 10%, Paul 7%, and Romney 5%.

Live North Carolina primary returns.

Again, not getting the media’s attention, on the Republican side: with 97% of the vote counted, the Republican percentages are: McCain 74%, Huckabee 12%, Paul 7%, and no preference 4%. And not being reported on CNN, Alan Keyes is getting 2.6% (source is the NC Board of Elections).

North Carolina Ballot Access Trial

On May 5, the first day of the North Carolina ballot access trial was held in state court in Raleigh. The hearing will also take most or all of May 6. The first day heard evidence from three Libertarian activists and one Green activist. The judge seemed very interested in the testimony. The state’s cross-examination seemed aimed at belittling the size of both the Libertarian and Green Parties. Here is an article from the Greensboro News & Record.