Illinois Republicans Attack Green Party Gubernatorial Candidate

On November 5, the chair of the Republican Party of Illinois, Andy McKenna, called a press conference to denounce the Green Party’s candidate for Governor, Richard Whitney. Whitney was a member of the Socialist Labor Party from the late 1970’s until 1993, and he was editor of the party’s national monthly newspaper, The People, 1989-1993.

Although convention wisdom dictates that the presence of Green Party candidates always injures Democrats, in the Illinois gubernatorial race, it is the Republican Party that fears the presence of the Green Party ticket. Republican gubernatorial nominee Judy Baar Topinka has attacked Whitney at least twice, but Democratic incumbent Governor Rod Blagojevich has refused to comment.

Whitney said “I became disenchanted with the philosophy and left the party in 1992, a year before he moved to Illinois (he had lived in California previously)…I have not been a socialist for 14 years. When I got out of college in the 70’s, there were a lot of radical political groups around, and because of my devotion to working people, I was initially attracted to the socialist ideology.” He added that he became convinced workers need “both a healthy public sector and healthy private sector.”

The Socialist Labor Party was the original party of socialism in the United States. All other U.S. parties with “socialist” in their name can trace their roots to the Socialist Labor Party. The party last ran a presidential candidate in 1976, and last appeared on the ballot in a partisan election in 1985.

4 More Gubernatorial Polls

Polls released on November 5 include:

Maine (Survey USA): Democrat John Baldacci 36%, Republican Chandler Woodcock 30%, independent state legislator Barbara Merrill 21%, Green Pat LaMarche 11%, other and undecided 2%. If LaMarche does get 11%, she will represent a new record for Green gubernatorial candidates, topping the 1994 Green showing in New Mexico of 10.3%.

Minnesota (Star Tribune Poll): Democrat Mike Hatch 45%, Republican Tim Pawlenty 40%, Independence Party Peter Hutchins 7%, other and undecided 8%.

Florida (Miami Herald poll): Republican Charlie Crist 48%, Democrat Jim Davis 38%, Reform Max Linn 3%, other and undecided 11%.

Texas (Dallas Morning News poll): Republican Rick Perry 39%, Democrat Chris Bell 22%, independent Carole Strayhorn 18%, independent Kinky Friedman 11%, Libertarian James Werner 1%, undecided 9%.

Will Greens Meet the Vote Test for Ongoing Ballot Qualification Status?

In most states, minor parties running for statewide office in 2006 need to poll a certain share of the vote in order to qualify automatically in 2008. Often it is easy to predict if a party will poll enough votes to remain on the ballot. This year, there are seven states that are tough to predict, and it is especially tough to predict how the Green Party will do.

Arkansas: will the Green Party poll 3% for Governor? The Governor’s race is a 4-way race between a Democrat, Republican, Green and independent. Polls have not generally included all 4 candidates.

Illinois: will the Green Party poll 5% for Governor? Polls have shown that it will, although the most recent poll showed the Green down to 7%.

Maryland: will the Green Party poll 1% for Governor? Maryland gubernatorial polls have not included all 4 candidates (nominees of the Democratic, Republican, Green and Populist Parties). Although the Maryland Green Party’s candidate for U.S. Senate has campaigned harder, only the gubernatorial race counts for ongoing status.

Minnesota: will the Green Party poll 5% for any statewide race? Greens are entered in four statewide races (US Senate, Governor-Lt. Gov, Auditor, Attorney General). Since the Independence Party also has nominees in each of those races, Greens face an uphill battle to recapture qualified status. In 2002, Greens contested 4 of the statewide offices but their best showing was 3.67%.

Nebraska: Greens have two statewide nominees, Secretary of State and Auditor, but both races have both a Democrat and a Republican running as well, so it’s tough to predict whether either Green will get the needed 5%. By contrast, the Constitution Party has a nominee in the 2-candidate Treasurer’s race, so the Constitution Party is sure to remain qualified.

New Mexico: will the Green nominee for Public Regulation Commission poll a vote total that is equal to 5% of the entire vote cast for Governor in the state? The Green is in a two-person race and has been campaigning hard; but since the state is divided into five Public Regulation districts, and since many voters will skip voting in this race, the Green probably needs 30% to 35% of the total vote cast, to meet the statewide 5% standard. Also the law isn’t clear on whether this race counts; a federal court a few months ago said it does, but a lower state court in 2004 said it doesn’t.

New York: will the Green Party poll 50,000 votes for Governor to regain its qualified status (which was also won in 1998 but lost in 2002)?

If the Green Party is lucky in all seven states, it will be ballot-qualified for president in 2008 (as of November 8, 2006) in 25 states, the same number it had immediately after the November 2000 election.

The Libertarian Party, as of November 8, 2006, is likely to be ballot-qualified for president in 2008 in 24 states, with an outside chance for two more, if it can get 5% for U.S. Senate in Washington, and 50,000 for New York Governor.

The Constitution Party, as of November 8, 2006, is likely to be ballot-qualified for president in 2008 in ten states, and the Working Families Party in five states.

An Appeal to Unity.08

Unity.08 leaders, so far, have shown no interest in working to improve ballot access laws, even though Unity.08 itself will be greatly injured by some of them. Unity.08 desires to sponsor an independent presidential candidate, chosen in the early summer of 2008 by millions of people using the internet.

However, laws that force an independent presidential candidate to complete rigorous petition drives by May or June interfere with Unity.08’s goal. Texas is particularly a problem, because it requires 74,108 signatures by early May, from the ranks of people who are registered but who don’t vote in the March 2008 primaries. Arizona’s independent petition number for 2008 can’t be known yet, but probably it will close to 25,000, due in early June.

These laws, and other laws, are forcing Unity.08 to create a political party, but that has disadvantages also. Once a party is created, it will be impossible for Unity.08 to prevent individuals from running for office as party members, for office other than president, yet Unity.08 says it doesn’t intend to run candidates for any office than president.

One would think, therefore, that Unity.08 would be working to ease the independent presidential petition laws. However, leaders of Unity.08 have expressed disinterest in any such activity. If you are part of Unity.08, please urge the organization to re-think this issue.