U.S. House Passes Bill Requiring Voters to Prove Citizenship When Registering to Vote, and to Show Photo I.D. Before Voting

On February 11, the U.S. House passed HR 7296, the “Save America Act” which requires people who wish to register to vote to show proof of citizenship, and which requires voters at the polls to show certain types if identification. The vote was 218-213. All Republicans voted for it, along with one Democrat, Henry Cuellar of Texas. Here is the text.

The bill only applies to federal elections, not elections for state or local office.


Comments

U.S. House Passes Bill Requiring Voters to Prove Citizenship When Registering to Vote, and to Show Photo I.D. Before Voting — 44 Comments

  1. If the valid forms of identification are not provided to all citizens free (ie, subsidized) of charge, then this is an unconstitutional poll tax as per the 24th Amendment to the United States Constitution. This “Save America Act” is not a valid Article V amendment process by which the 24th Amendment can be overridden.

    https://www.law.cornell.edu/constitution/amendmentxxiv

  2. Certainly a good first step. Now get a bill passed to ban gerrymandering and require bonafide independent panels to draw the districts.

  3. USA CITIZENS

    1. 19 APR 1775-4 JULY 1776 ORIGINALS – 13 STATES
    2. 1775-1790 STATE NATURALIZATIONS – NC / RI LATE
    3. 1777-1791 VERMONT – SPECIAL – STATE 14
    4. 1790 ONWARD – VARIOUS USA NATURALIZATION LAWS
    5. SOME SECTIONS IN VARIOUS TREATIES – OPTION FOR FOREIGN ADULTS IN ADDED USA AREAS TO BECOME USA CITIZENS
    6. CHILDREN ALLEGIANCE/NATION STATE STATUS VIA ALLEGED FATHERS
    —-
    7. PLACE OF BIRTH MEANS ZERO

    8. MAJOR PROBLEM — MOST OLDE BIRTH CERTIFICATES DO N-O-T SHOW NATION-STATE STATUS OF ALLEGED FATHERS

  4. D Frank Robinson also supports fraud and illegals, no wonder why he wants people to vote in multiple states.

  5. Real Facts

    “AZ spambot,

    As always, if President Trump was a tyrant, you would be deprogrammed, your programmers would be in prison, and this website would be taken down.”

    Duh!

  6. Forever Trump, I want to have forever Trump
    Do you really want Trump as President forever?
    Forever, and ever
    Forever Trump, I want to have forever Trump

    Do you really want Trump forever?
    Forever Trump!

  7. Relax and don’t worry, it’s going to be fine. The White People’s movement keeps getting bigger all the time. I’m dreaming of a White nation, just like the ones that I once knew. And now with mass deportation, my dream is starting to come true!

  8. I support Donald Trump by supporting White Power and I support White Power by supporting Donald Trump!

  9. I like the idea of deporting all criminal aliens, including misdemeanors. If they have been naturalized, that should involve denaturalization, and birthright citizenship should be retroactively stripped from the children of illegals. Being present in the country illegally should also be sufficient for immediate deportation. I would also denaturalize and deport any citizen who provides illegals with housing or employment. And any legal resident or naturalized citizen ever convicted of any crime (felony or misdemeanor).

    100 million deportations would be a great start. Let’s make it happen!

  10. We have to treat the alien invasion as a life threatening form of aggressive malignant cancer and take any and all extreme measures to remove it before it kills our homeland. We must cut out all vestiges of it and completely cleanse our country of the infection.

    Our genetic heritage is the single most important thing to preserve in the world, far more important than any of our individual lives or any sacrifice that we will have to endure to purify ourselves.

  11. To the extent we’ve become ever more of a democracy through overextended voting rights since 1776, that has made things worse, not better. A full blown democracy would quickly result in full blown communist tyranny as the moronic majority vote their rights away for a handful of other people’s money.

  12. The evil sinister left must be defeated by any and all means necessary to save America, save Christendom, and save European based civilization. God bless President Trump!

  13. It’s too bad the AZ-666 SPAMBOT cant be programmed to only work in North Korea so it could see what a real tyrant does as it gets deprogrammed in a horrific manner.

  14. Democracy is always a race to the bottom of a bottomless pit – governance by the lowest common denominator of a continuously dumbed down product of multigenerational broken families, propaganda mills, filthy vulgar entertainment, brain eating social media, population replacement, breeding by the dumbest (see idiocracy), the lazy and stupid voting tax extorted welfare for themselves, chemical warfare through narcoterrorism, etc.

    Christian White Nationalists must create our own independent living spaces, whether as anarcho-capitalist enclaves or as neofeudal, theocratic, or Capitalist meritocratic micronations with very limited voting rights along a corporate shareholder model.

    We’ve seen what continuously diluting the (breeding) stock does to a constitutional republic. It’s time to learn the lessons and terminate a failed experiment before we get to full third world status or worse.

  15. Trump is only a first step. We must move much, much further to the right.

  16. The problems boil down to giving voting rights to a whole bunch of people who shouldn’t have ever had them, which goes hand in hand with them voting themselves ever more of other people’s money, ever more burdensome regulations, voting to bring in additional welfare parasites, spies, terrorists, commies and criminals from every part of the world.

  17. Things really started to go to hell quickly when they started letting broads vote. They need to get back in the kitchen and let men make decisions, especially in politics.

  18. HOW MANY KILLED/INJURED//ENSLAVED IN FOREIGN / CIVIL WARS VIA MONARCHS/OLIGARCHS [THE MOGS] VS DEMOCRATS SINCE ADAM AND EVE ???

    DOWN WITH ALL MONARCH/OLIGARCH REGIMES — OFTEN FULL OF LAWLESS TYRANTS

    PR
    APPV
    TOTSOP

  19. A majority of moronic sheep dumbed down by several generations of propaganda, addicted to consumerism and cheap thrills, and bred like farm animals for their docile traits one generation after another will certainly march democratically to the slaughterhouses, bleeting the whole way.

  20. Monarchy can be bad, but it isn’t as bad as dumbocracy. With monarchy, a mad tyrant king can be deposed. With dumbocracy, bad incentives create increasingly bad outcomes over time. Limited government constitutional republic is better than both, but there are inadequate safeguards from sliding downwards into dumbocracy, so they need to be significantly tightened up. The changes in our form of government since the time of the founder’s have all been for the worse and worse. So, we need changes that don’t just go back to their original system but change things in the opposite direction along multiple axes and make future changes after that much more difficult.

  21. said:
    If you expect anything good to come out of politics and government, you’re going to be disappointed. Quit digging yourself and everyone else a deeper hole. Pick up a gun or a shovel and do something useful. Don’t forget to pray.

  22. Puerto Rico is a real democracy. Whites are already a minority there, and in DC. Obviously they are run much better than the 50 States, like every other nonWhite majority democracy on the planet.

    Let’s make them States and import ourselves a nonWhite future voting majority of criminals, lunatics, terrorists, welfare parasites, religious cults etc from every part of the world so we can be a wonderful democracy too!

  23. “With dumbocracy, bad incentives create increasingly bad outcomes over time.”

    …and everyone can point fingers at each other, with the buck not stopping anywhere. Replacing this or that politician or law doesn’t fundamentally change anything. The tyrant isn’t a person, it’s a toxic combination of the lowest common denominator voter and a flawed system. See Hoppe, “Democracy: the God that Failed.”

  24. Yeah, newspapers and radio stations where people bitched freely about Hitler and public demonstrations against him were a big thing in Nazi Germany. Oh wait..

  25. A Respectful Plea Regarding the Comment Section

    Mr. Winger,

    Ballot Access News has for many years been a uniquely valuable resource. It has served as a clearinghouse of information on ballot access law, minor parties, election procedure, and constitutional developments that few other outlets track with such consistency and depth. Scholars, journalists, minor party activists, attorneys, and politically engaged citizens across the ideological spectrum have relied on it.

    For that very reason, the state of the comment section is increasingly troubling.

    In recent threads, the comments are no longer primarily about ballot access, election law, or the substance of the post. Instead, they are dominated by explicitly racialist rhetoric, open white nationalist slogans, calls for stripping citizenship retroactively, praise for authoritarian alternatives to democracy, and even occasional suggestions of violence. These are not merely sharp partisan exchanges. They go far beyond normal ideological disagreement.

    This shift matters—not because political disagreement should be suppressed, but because the visible culture of a site inevitably reflects on the credibility of the site itself.

    There is a well-documented pattern in online communities: when moderation is minimal or absent, highly motivated extremists tend to dominate the conversation. They post early and often. They reinforce one another. More moderate readers gradually stop commenting. Over time, the apparent “voice” of the site becomes the loudest and most transgressive voices, even if they represent only a small fraction of the readership.

    This dynamic can quietly capture a comment section.

    The problem is not that Ballot Access News reports on controversial subjects. Election law is inherently political. The problem is that the comment section increasingly reads like a gathering place for people advocating ethnic cleansing, mass denaturalization, authoritarian governance, and racial hierarchy. That environment discourages serious engagement. It drives away thoughtful commenters who might otherwise contribute meaningful legal or historical insights.

    Ballot access law depends on cross-ideological credibility. Minor parties span the entire political spectrum. Election reform debates require trust from people who disagree profoundly with one another. When the comment section is saturated with openly racist or authoritarian rhetoric, it risks undermining that credibility.

    There is also a reputational dimension. Journalists, academics, and legal professionals notice the overall environment of a site. Even if the reporting remains careful and factual, an unmoderated comment section that prominently features white nationalist advocacy can change how the publication is perceived and cited.

    Moderation does not require censorship of disagreement. It can mean:

    Removing explicit racial supremacist advocacy.

    Deleting calls for violence.

    Enforcing relevance to the topic of the post.

    Limiting repetitive spamming.

    Requiring basic standards of civility.

    Many serious outlets have had to confront this issue. Some have moved to moderated comments. Others have required pre-approval for new commenters. Some have chosen to disable comments entirely when they could no longer maintain constructive discourse.

    Whatever solution you believe appropriate, doing nothing allows the most extreme voices to define the visible character of the discussion.

    Ballot Access News has been too important for too long to let its public face be shaped by those who advocate dismantling democratic governance along racial lines. Even those who strongly support President Trump or favor restrictive immigration policies deserve a space for substantive, legally grounded argument—not a comment thread overwhelmed by slogans and racialist manifestos.

    This plea is offered respectfully and in recognition of the enormous work you have done over the years. The reporting itself remains valuable. That is precisely why the comment section matters.

    I hope you will consider steps to restore the discussion to something worthy of the seriousness of the subject matter.

  26. In other words, troll Alden James is all in a snit about having to read opinions she doesn’t agree with. Opinions have to fall within her approved range of acceptable opinions or else get censored because they cause her to get triggered due to causing her cognitive dissonance.

  27. This is far from the first or only time communist control freak wannabe censor nutcase Arden James has called for all viewpoints she doesn’t like to be censored.

  28. Why doesn’t she just stop reading the comments instead of trying to control other people’s views and freedom of expression? And, what particular views triggered her totalitarian knee jerk spasm for nuclear option censorship this time?

    Notice she has no problem with the AZ SPAMBOT and its endless calls for the assassination of President Trump?

  29. In France, citizens register at 16 YO, when they are automatically registered to vote.

    In Texas, there could be registration for the militia at age 18, with all issued an ID and registered to vote. Others would be registered when they move to the state, or update their address.

    With statewide record of adult citizens, there is no reason to depend on the US Census for districting purposes.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.