North Carolina Ballot Access Bill Introduced

On April 10, several North Carolina legislators from both major parties introduced HB 794, to improve ballot access. The bill lowers the number of signatures for newly-qualifying parties, and statewide independent candidates, from 2% of the last gubernatorial vote cast, to one-fourth of 1% of that same base. For 2014, this would reduce the petition from 89,340 signatures to 11,168 signatures.

The bill also moves the petition deadline from mid-May to early July, and lowers the vote test for a party to remain on the ballot from 2% for President or Governor, to one-fourth of 1% for President or Governor. Parties with less than 10% of the voter registration would be permitted to nominate by convention instead of by primary.

Independent candidate petitions for district office would be lowered from 4% of the number of registered voters, to 1%.

If the bill passes as written, the only states that would require more than 50,000 signatures in 2014 for a newly-qualifying party would be California, Georgia, and Oklahoma. Thanks to Brian Irving for the news about the bill.

Maryland Legislature Adjourns; Bills to Restrict Petitioning Fail to Pass

Early on April 9, the Maryland legislature adjourned for the year. Two bills to vastly increase the difficult of petitioning in Maryland failed to pass. They were HB 493 and SB 673. They had provided that signers of petitions must include their date of birth, and mandated that each page of the petition inform signers that all the information on the petition would be a public record. The bills also made it illegal for the circulator of the petition to sign a petition sheet as a voter. And it would have barred anyone from petitioning unless he or she had first taken a course provided by election officials. Thanks to Paul Jacob for this news.

New York City Libertarian Party Makes Awkard Start for Nominating for New York City Offices

On April 9, the New York city Libertarian Party held a nominating convention, and nominated Joe Lhota for Mayor and Kristin Davis for Comptroller. However, Lhota (who does favor decriminalizing marijuana) then said he would not accept the Libertarian nomination. He is one of the candidates seeking the Republican nomination.

It is alleged that Lhota would not have won the Libertarian nomination, except that 40 newcomers attended the convention and cast votes for him. It is conceivable that the party will now hold a new citywide nominating convention.

Washington State Green Party Plaintiffs Win Procedural Victory in Case Involving Secret Ballots

On March 27, some voters in San Juan County, Washington, won a procedural victory in State Superior Court in White v Reed. This is a lawsuit arguing that San Juan County should not print unique barcodes on ballots because they could conceivably be used to violate secrecy in voting. The Court ruled that the plaintiffs, who are associated with the Green Party, do have standing. The Court also ruled that the barcodes are considered part of “voting system software” and cannot be used unless the state certifies the program that produces the bar codes.

There is still no decision on the issue of whether use of the barcodes could violate ballot secrecy. That will probably require a trial, and the Superior Court Judge postponed that until San Juan County and the Secretary of State have an opportunity to try to reverse the procedural ruling. The case is White v Reed, 10-2-05002-8. The decision relies partly on Bush v Gore. One of the arguments the plaintiffs make is that they are not treated equally because their county uses bar codes and most counties in Washington state do not.

Opponents of Rhode Island Straight-Ticket Device Publicize New Study, Showing How Device Probably Changes Outcomes

Bills are pending in the Rhode Island legislature to abolish the straight-ticket device. On April 10, supporters of those bills released a study, showing that in November 2012, the Speaker of the House would probably have been defeated by an independent candidate if the straight-ticket device did not exist.

Only two candidates were on the ballot in November 2012 in the State House race for the 4th district: Gordon Fox, the Democratic nominee and the House speaker; and independent candidate Mark Binder. The vote was: Fox 3,590; Binder 2,595. In that district, 1,469 voters used the straight-ticket device for the Democratic Party. This shows that the voters who did not use the straight-ticket device preferred Binder. The data suggests, but cannot prove, that the straight-ticket device changes election outcomes. Independent candidates do not have their own straight-ticket device, and it is probable that most of the voters in 2012 who used the straight-ticket device didn’t even notice who the candidates for State House were.